Imagine not being allowed to adopt a child you had raised since birth. That is what some same-sex partners are facing. Michigan is among a handful of states that still offers no legal protections for gays and lesbians – and that can have major consequences for their children.Yeah, explain to me how this state of the law is good for children. It doesn't prevent gay people from adopting, it doesn't prevent gay people from parenting, if that's the goal of the lawmakers. It just makes sure that children are punished because some policy makers disapprove of the families their parents have created.
* * *
A local lesbian couple has been raising three children since birth, kids who otherwise would have been in the foster care system. One of the women adopted one child – while the other woman had to adopt the other two – that’s because the law in Michigan won’t let them jointly adopt all three kids. And they’re hoping this lawsuit will change the lives of children all over Michigan.
April Deboer and Jayne Rowse have dedicated their lives to raising three small children – two of whom have special needs. April and Jayne are both nurses – and they have been in a committed relationship for more than a decade.
* * *
Because the Michigan Constitution bans same-sex marriage – same-sex couples cannot jointly adopt children.
“I don’t see how that puts the best interest of the child at the forefront,” says Rowse.
* * *
Nessel says the legal rights of children of same-sex couples are being hurt in many ways. If one of their parents dies, the other parent would have no legal claim to the child.
“So in the event something happened to her, not only would her children lose their mom, but they would also lose the only other parent they know and their sibling,” says Doboer.
Also, when April takes the boys to the doctor, she has to take Jayne with her. “I can’t legally sign for treatments. I can’t legally sign for anything. I have to wait for her to show up to the hospital in order to get treatment,” she says.
Lawyers say the children of same-sex couples also don’t have the same inheritance rights that other kids do. They also can’t receive social security disability from the non-adoptive parent, or health insurance. Also if a same-sex couple separates, they have no legal ability to see the children that they didn’t adopt.
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Same-Sex Couple Sues Over Michigan's Ban on Second Parent Adoption for Unmarried Parents
I've posted before about the benefits of second-parent adoption to protect families and children. A local TV station reports on a lesbian couple in Michigan suing over the ban on unmarried parents jointly adopting:
DNA Testing Leads Some Adoptees to Family
Interesting article in the New York Times:
I rarely agree with Elizabeth Bartholet (as illustrated here), but I do agree with what she had to say in this NYT piece: "Elizabeth Bartholet, an expert on adoption at Harvard Law School, said the proliferation of testing highlights the need for broader access to adoption records." But no need to worry, the agreement didn't last long -- the next sentence is pretty obnoxious: "In the meantime, she says, adoptees would be better served by nurturing the relationships they already have." Right, just ignore your roots and concentrate on your adoptive family!
Growing up, Khrys Vaughan always believed that she had inherited her looks and mannerisms from her father, and that her appreciation for tradition and old-fashioned gentility stemmed from her parents’ Southern roots. But those facets of her self-image crumbled when she was told, at age 42, that she had been adopted.
She began searching for her origins, only to find out that her adoption records had been sealed, a common practice in the 1960s. Then Mrs. Vaughan stumbled across an ad from a DNA testing company offering to help people who had been adopted find clues to their ancestry and connections to blood relatives.
About five weeks after shipping off two tiny vials of her cells from a swab of her cheek, Mrs. Vaughan received an e-mail informing her that her bloodlines extended to France, Romania and West Africa. She was also given the names and e-mail addresses of a dozen distant cousins. This month, she drove 208 miles from her hometown here to Evansville, Ind., to meet her third cousin, the first relative to respond to her e-mails. Mrs. Vaughan is black and her cousin is white, and they have yet to find their common ancestor. But Mrs. Vaughan says that does not matter.
“Somebody is related to me in this world,” she said. “Somebody out there has my blood. I can look at her and say, ‘This is my family.’”The article seems to accept as a given that adoption records are sealed. If that's an immutable thing, then of course DNA testing -- with its expense and imperfect ability to track relatives -- is a work-around that allows some to find some family. But doesn't the problem really speak to a different solution -- unsealing the records or not sealing them in the first place? The article provides evidence of that -- DNA tests allowed Khrys Vaughan to find a 3rd cousin, but unsealing her adoption records is what allowed her to find her birth mother.
I rarely agree with Elizabeth Bartholet (as illustrated here), but I do agree with what she had to say in this NYT piece: "Elizabeth Bartholet, an expert on adoption at Harvard Law School, said the proliferation of testing highlights the need for broader access to adoption records." But no need to worry, the agreement didn't last long -- the next sentence is pretty obnoxious: "In the meantime, she says, adoptees would be better served by nurturing the relationships they already have." Right, just ignore your roots and concentrate on your adoptive family!
Monday, January 23, 2012
Cooking in the Chinese New Year
Last summer I attended a cooking demonstration class by Grace Young, known as The Wok Queen, The Poet Laureate of the Wok, and a Wok Evangelist, and author of lots of cookbooks. She's sharing three health-conscious stir-fry recipes at Weight Watchers, in honor Chinese New Year.
She also talks a little about Chinese New Year customs, and the importance of food:
She also talks a little about Chinese New Year customs, and the importance of food:
What part does food play in all this?I'm definitely going to try the Stir-Fried Garlic Lettuce recipe. It might sound strange to Western palates to cook lettuce, but we frequently had stir-fried lettuce (and cucumbers, too, which also sounds strange to cook!) in China, and it was yummy!
A huge one. Everything we eat during the holiday has a symbolic meaning. When friends come to visit we offer tea and sweets because sweet food guarantees a sweet year. Sometimes a food looks like something you want: scallops and dumplings are supposed to resemble ancient Chinese coins. Or a food's name may have the same sound as the name of something desirable. People eat lettuce because the word sounds like “growing fortune,” fish because the word sounds like “abundance,” and sweet-and-sour dishes because “sour” has the same sound as “grandchildren.”
Traveling Abroad to Find Home
The Washington Post profiles an internationally adopted teen on a homeland/birth parent reunion tour. Here's a sample:
As her father catnapped at her side, Deanna Torstenson’s heart pounded and her body trembled. She fixed her eyes on the tiny airplane moving across a video screen on the seat back in front of her. Slowly it approached Astana, the capital of Kazakhstan. Soon, for the first time, she would set eyes on the woman who had given birth to her.The article covers a lot of territory, including adoptee identity issues, birth parent reactions to being found, adoptive parents' reactions to their child's desire to search, etc. And it turns out that the birth mom did not really relinquish the child, she was told the child died. So go read the whole thing.
“I’d never been in the presence of anyone who was actually biologically related to me,” she later recalled. “So I was like, ‘Oh my gosh, oh my gosh, oh my gosh. . . . This is really happening!’ ”
Deanna, 17, who was adopted 15 years ago from a Kazakhstan orphanage and grew up in Springfield, had always felt an invisible thread connecting her to a biological family, long before she ever knew they existed.
Her parents had provided a loving home and all the trappings of American life — at West Springfield High School, she sings classical music and does madrigals in musical theater.
But Deanna couldn’t stop wondering about from where — and whom — she had come. Now, as her plane lowered over Central Asia, she was about to find out.
Sunday, January 22, 2012
Chinese New Year, Dragons, and Red Underwear
In 2007, we arrived in China right after the Chinese New Year for our 5-month stay. Our apartment was on the college campus where I taught, and as usual, we frequently saw laundry hanging to dry from balconies and dorm windows (we hung our laundry to dry, too, as the photo above shows!). One odd thing I noticed was the number of items of RED underwear hanging out to dry. Panties, boxers, bras, all in red! I thought that was quite hotsy-totsy for college students! But I soon learned that it wasn't a Victoria's Secret inspired fashion trend -- it was protection:
For those turning 12, 24, 36 etc. (the Chinese Zodiac uses a cycle of 12), termed benming nian, or the meeting of one’s zodiac year, traditional Chinese belief is that it can be an unlucky year. To ward off any dangers that might befall you in your benming nian, it helps to wear red. Red is one of the luckiest colors in Chinese traditions, standing for loyalty, success and happiness.So all of those 24-year-old college/grad students had all been gifted red underwear for the dangerous Zodiac year!
If you’re really traditional, you should wear red every day, all year long. If you’re not a big fan of the color red in your outer wardrobe, red underwear is an easy way to protect yourself against the hazards of benming nian.
Zoe was born in the Year of the Dragon, so this year is her first repeat Zodiac year. We're lucky that her school uniform includes a red sweater or sweatshirt, so she's covered (in more ways than one!) during the week. But what about weekends?!
We went looking for red underwear for her today, and found PLENTY in adult sizes and risque styles given the proximity to Valentine's Day. But for little girls? Not so much (I suppose I should be relieved they don't have little girl panties in red, given that red underwear has the "sexy" connotation. But that doesn't usually stop the designers -- I once saw a pair of 2T underwear with the word "HOTTIE" on the front. Yikes!). Might have to dye a few pairs to get Zoe through the Year of the Dragon. . . . .
Happy New Year to you all, and for those meeting the Year of the Dragon at age 12, 24, 36, 48, etc., best wishes for protection and lots of red underwear!
Russia With No Orphans?
At Voice of Russia, Russia’s Ombudsman for Children’s Rights Pavel Astakhov says that within 5 years, there will be an end to orphanhood in Russia:
Despite the signing of agreements on cooperation in the field of adoption between Russia on the one hand and the USA and France on the other, and earlier between Russia and Italy in the outgoing year, Russia’s Ombudsman for Children’s Rights Pavel Astakhov believes that child adoption by foreigners is a temporary phenomenon in this country. “Russia needs 5 years to do away with orphanhood”, Astakhov says, adding that “only specialized orphanages for children who need a complex medical care will remain in this country”.
Hot debates around child adoption by foreigners are currently underway in the Russian society. The supporters of this idea say that first of all, this is good for children themselves since only handicapped children are taken abroad. But in reality the situation is somewhat different, Astakhov says.
"Last year foreign citizens adopted 3,355 children. Out of these 3,355 only 4 per cent – to be more exact, 148 children were handicapped. Which means that Americans adopted 44 disabled children out of more than 1,000. Russian citizens adopt disabled children far more willingly."
There’s one more thing that should be mentioned here - they say that foreigners adopt the children which were rejected by potential adoptive parents in Russia. In reality, they adopt children under 3 years old, that is, the children for the adoption of which Russian citizens are queuing. People also say that foreigners pay children’s surgical operations, thus, saving their lives. Meanwhile, in Russia high-tech medical help was offered to more than 50, 000 children, including orphans in the first place, last year.
* * *
Some time ago Russia’s Ombudsman for Children’s Rights Pavel Astakhov and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov signed a joint address to the Supreme Court, with a request for the necessity of introducing a moratorium on adoption by foreigners. Astakhov is sure that Russia needs 5 years to do away with orphanages and that children who need adoption will be taken into adoptive families in Russia.
Saturday, January 21, 2012
School Interview & Issues of Identity
We've applied for a new school for Zoe, starting next year, for middle school (YIKES! Next year I'll have a middle schooler!). The school is an all-girls school that specializes in math, science and technology, the Young Women's Leadership Academy. Zoe is really excited about this possibility, and my job has been to try to manage her expectations -- though it's a public school, admission isn't guaranteed. The application included teacher recommendations, a two-page essay, and a personal interview -- just as complicated as college application!
Today was the personal interview. Though it was only 10 minutes, Zoe was pretty nervous about it, which is what I'd expect. She's quite capable of sailing through it and being quite impressive, but she's also quite capable of turning shy and barely saying a word. She probably pretty much hit the middle ground (I wasn't allowed in the interview!), but some of that was just luck. When we got to the room where she would be interviewed, it turned out to be the Chinese classroom! I think she saw it as a good omen that she could read the characters above the door. There were two interviewers, and one was the Chinese teacher!
If Zoe were applying for a Chinese school, I'd say she was in! For a math, science and technology school? Not so sure!
The first question they asked her was an ice-breaking open-ended, "Tell us something about yourself." Zoe told them she was born in China. The Chinese teacher asked her where in China she was born and how old she was when she came to America. No problem, Zoe answered that. The teacher asked her to say something in Chinese, and Zoe told them her name and age in Chinese. They asked her what her long-term goals were, and consistent with this theme, she said she wanted to learn more about China than she already knew (I love that she had to throw in there that she already knew stuff about China!). Finally, they asked her why she wanted to attend YWLA, and she explained that she had been bullied at her school for being -- you guessed it -- Chinese, and she didn't think it would happen at a school like YWLA where there were kids from lots of different places. None of this would be a surprise to the interviewers if they read her essay -- she included all of this. But she also talked about her interest in science and technology in that essay.
So you see why I think she nailed the interview if it were for a Chinese school?! Not one mention of math, science and technology, though. Ah, well. It wouldn't be a problem if we stayed where we are -- it would actually be easier for me since I wouldn't have to deal with two different schools on two different schedules. But Zoe would really be disappointed. . . .
The thing I found interesting, and why I wanted to share it here, is how important, how fundamental, being Chinese is to Zoe identity. When asked about herself, it's the first thing she shares. Her long-term goals are wrapped up in being Chinese (in her essay, she said she wanted to be a scientist or a science teacher, but that she wanted to work in both China and America, and help the two countries learn more about each other, so even there, when talking about science, etc., it gets wrapped up in being Chinese). To her, being Chinese is her identity.
I also think it's interesting that she now separates her identity as adopted from her identity as Chinese. At one time, being adopted would have been the first thing she mentioned, and being Chinese and being adopted meant the same thing, since most everyone she knew who was adopted was Chinese and just about everyone she knew who was Chinese was adopted. Attending Chinese School, and living in China in 2007, helped her to divorce the two. Now, this doesn't mean she doesn't think of herself as adopted, that she doesn't still have issues surrounding adoption. But at least right now, race/ethnicity is trumping adoption.
All musings aside, please say a prayer, light a candle, send out good vibrations, wish us luck, keep your fingers crossed -- we won't know for a month whether she got in, but we can use all the help you can offer!
Today was the personal interview. Though it was only 10 minutes, Zoe was pretty nervous about it, which is what I'd expect. She's quite capable of sailing through it and being quite impressive, but she's also quite capable of turning shy and barely saying a word. She probably pretty much hit the middle ground (I wasn't allowed in the interview!), but some of that was just luck. When we got to the room where she would be interviewed, it turned out to be the Chinese classroom! I think she saw it as a good omen that she could read the characters above the door. There were two interviewers, and one was the Chinese teacher!
If Zoe were applying for a Chinese school, I'd say she was in! For a math, science and technology school? Not so sure!
The first question they asked her was an ice-breaking open-ended, "Tell us something about yourself." Zoe told them she was born in China. The Chinese teacher asked her where in China she was born and how old she was when she came to America. No problem, Zoe answered that. The teacher asked her to say something in Chinese, and Zoe told them her name and age in Chinese. They asked her what her long-term goals were, and consistent with this theme, she said she wanted to learn more about China than she already knew (I love that she had to throw in there that she already knew stuff about China!). Finally, they asked her why she wanted to attend YWLA, and she explained that she had been bullied at her school for being -- you guessed it -- Chinese, and she didn't think it would happen at a school like YWLA where there were kids from lots of different places. None of this would be a surprise to the interviewers if they read her essay -- she included all of this. But she also talked about her interest in science and technology in that essay.
So you see why I think she nailed the interview if it were for a Chinese school?! Not one mention of math, science and technology, though. Ah, well. It wouldn't be a problem if we stayed where we are -- it would actually be easier for me since I wouldn't have to deal with two different schools on two different schedules. But Zoe would really be disappointed. . . .
The thing I found interesting, and why I wanted to share it here, is how important, how fundamental, being Chinese is to Zoe identity. When asked about herself, it's the first thing she shares. Her long-term goals are wrapped up in being Chinese (in her essay, she said she wanted to be a scientist or a science teacher, but that she wanted to work in both China and America, and help the two countries learn more about each other, so even there, when talking about science, etc., it gets wrapped up in being Chinese). To her, being Chinese is her identity.
I also think it's interesting that she now separates her identity as adopted from her identity as Chinese. At one time, being adopted would have been the first thing she mentioned, and being Chinese and being adopted meant the same thing, since most everyone she knew who was adopted was Chinese and just about everyone she knew who was Chinese was adopted. Attending Chinese School, and living in China in 2007, helped her to divorce the two. Now, this doesn't mean she doesn't think of herself as adopted, that she doesn't still have issues surrounding adoption. But at least right now, race/ethnicity is trumping adoption.
All musings aside, please say a prayer, light a candle, send out good vibrations, wish us luck, keep your fingers crossed -- we won't know for a month whether she got in, but we can use all the help you can offer!
Friday, January 20, 2012
Adoption isn't the only placement route to a happy childhood
So says the headline at the Guardian (UK), with the subhead, As ministers plan to simplify the adoption process, children's services are keen to promote other forms of long-term guardianship. Despite the headline, the article is mostly about adoption, with the exception of this paragraph:
What do you think of these alternatives to adoption? Pros and cons?
The ADCS points out that adoption is not right for every child and is rare in most countries except the UK and the US. Evidence suggests that children can do just as well in other forms of stable placements such as long-term fostering and "special guardianship" – a court order that gives a guardian legal parental responsibility for a child without removing responsibility altogether from the birth parents.
What do you think of these alternatives to adoption? Pros and cons?
Thursday, January 19, 2012
High School Newspaper Censored as Bullying for Anti-Gay-Adoption Editorial
Here's a new twist on bullying -- an interesting story out of Wisconsin, where a high school newspaper ran pro and con editorials about gay adoption, to the distress of gay parents whose children attended the school:
But as a parent? Maybe my desire to protect my children makes me a tad more sympathetic to the position of the school administration. I wouldn't want my kids to read stupid articles that opined on the inappropriateness of single parenting or transracial adoption or international adoption, or the inferiority of China or the like, and I would be worried that such an article would make other students more willing to bully my kids. But on the other hand, the articles here offered both arguments for and against, the audience was high school and not younger kids, and I guarantee that my kids would have already heard all the pro and con opinions folks harbor about our family structure before they ever saw such an article. But on the other other hand, should my kids have to deal with those obnoxious opinions in school, which should be a safe harbor?!
Reactions?
A gay couple with school-age children is outraged over a Shawano High School newspaper column that cites Bible passages and calls homosexuality a sin punishable by death.So what do you think? Should the student newspaper be able to publish controversial opinions that may adversely affect some students? I'm pretty much a First Amendment purist, but the Supreme Court isn't when in comes to school papers. The court has said that school administrations can in fact censor school newspapers so long as they have a reasonable educational justification, as I learned to my displeasure as a high school newspaper editor! Preventing bullying, creating a non-discriminatory learning environment, should qualify as a reasonable educational justification for limiting hateful student speech in the newspaper, right? I don't think I would have bought that argument as a high schooler, opinionated on rights and the perogatives of journalists.
The column ran on the editorial page of Shawano High School's Hawks Post recently as part of an opinion package about gay families who adopt children. The other side said sexual orientation does not determine a person's ability to raise kids.
"This is why kids commit suicide," said Nick Uttecht, who is raising four children with his partner, Michael McNelly.
Uttecht told school district officials he thinks the piece opposing gays as parents is hateful and should not have run. He worries the strong language will hurt his children and could lead students to bully gay classmates.
School officials apologized and said they will review the process for editing and producing the paper.
* * *
David Hudson, an expert for the Washington, D.C.-based advocacy group First Amendment Center, said the column may be distasteful to some, but student journalists were practicing their constitutional right to free speech.
"Bullying is a serious concern, and I don't take it lightly. But I hope it doesn't lead to squashing different viewpoints. I do think (gay adoption) is an issue people are deeply divided about. Hopefully student journalists don't have to fear they'll be squashed if they take a controversial view."
* * *
Although students have the right to voice their opinion, it doesn't mean they should say it in a school paper, said Christine Smith, assistant professor of psychology, human development and women's studies at the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay.
"High school students are at a time in their life when they are developing intellectually and socially," she said. "To see something like this debated in the paper could be devastating. How would you feel if someone said your family is abnormal, is not acceptable, that your parents never should have been allowed to have you, that they're not suitable to raise you?
"Of course, it's got to be harmful. Kids this age are so worried about discovering who they are and what they are. To have them told their family is immoral and not suitable has to be devastating. To be told by your peers, people you see in the hallways, these people who clearly have passed judgment."
But as a parent? Maybe my desire to protect my children makes me a tad more sympathetic to the position of the school administration. I wouldn't want my kids to read stupid articles that opined on the inappropriateness of single parenting or transracial adoption or international adoption, or the inferiority of China or the like, and I would be worried that such an article would make other students more willing to bully my kids. But on the other hand, the articles here offered both arguments for and against, the audience was high school and not younger kids, and I guarantee that my kids would have already heard all the pro and con opinions folks harbor about our family structure before they ever saw such an article. But on the other other hand, should my kids have to deal with those obnoxious opinions in school, which should be a safe harbor?!
Reactions?
Wednesday, January 18, 2012
Asian Americans as Targets of Bullying
Given this incident and this incident and this incident and this incident, it didn't surprise me that Zoe included in her "I have a dream" speech on MLK Day the dream "that children will not be bullied because of their race." At CNN's inAMERICA blog, Jeff Yang writes about the bullying-related deaths of Private Danny Chen and Lance Corporal Harry Lew, and more generally about Asian Americans as a growing target for bullies:
The more appropriate term for what Chen and Lew faced is targeted bullying — and it's something that's hardly limited to the military.What are you doing to protect your children from and prepare them for race-based bullying?
In fact, recent research suggests that young Asian Americans are facing a bullying epidemic. Last year, the U.S. Departments of Justice and Education released a joint study showing that over half of Asian American teens said they'd been the subject of targeted abuse at school, versus around a third of blacks, Hispanics and whites.
* * *
Why are Asian Americans disproportionately targeted for abuse?
A harmonic convergence of factors. There's the perception — and in some cases, the reality — of the "nerd" stereotype. The trinity of social awkwardness, physical frailty and academic overachievement has always served as a magnet for bullies.
There's the rising tide of animosity toward immigrants, particularly those from predominantly countries that are seen as emerging rivals of the United States, like China and India.
There's the plain old fact that those who are "different" in obvious ways — appearance, name, faith, accent — are often the focus of unwanted attention in environments where fitting in is prized, like high school. Or the military.
And especially among immigrants and the children of immigrants, there's the reality that cultural and familial expectations push them to submit to bullying rather than being "disruptive" or succumbing to "distraction."
Study: Black children form identity through race, not language
I thought this study was particularly interesting in light of the NYT piece I posted earlier in the week, about how Latinos identify by language and culture rather than by race:
Black children in the same age group tend to form their identity more strongly by the color of their skin than a shared language, according to a new study, while the opposite was true for white children.
A study published in the November issue of Developmental Science and conducted by University of Chicago researchers Katherine Kinzler and Jacelyn Dautel presented some preliminary findings regarding how young children identify with others.
According to a report in the Journal of Blacks in Higher Education, the study cites four experiments, each designed to provide a specific piece of information and control for some variables. Experiments 1, 2 and 4 used children ages five to six, while experiment 3 used children ages nine to 10.
Experiments 1, 2, and 3 used White children and experiment 4 used Black children. In all the experiments, the children. In all the experiments, the children were shown a child and adults and asked, “Which adult does this child grow up to be?”
In experiments 1 and 2, the children picked the adult that spoke the same language as the child in the test, though it was not a racial match. In experiments 3 and 4, the children picked the adult that was a racial match, though they were not a language match to the child in the test.
“The difference between European American and African American children of the same age highlights the potential role of experience in facilitating children’s reasoning about the stability of different social categories,” the researchers wrote.
Washington State Notes Spike in Starvation of Adopted Children
A commenter mentioned this report in the comments to the Right/Wrong reasons to adopt post, so I thought I'd move it "above the fold," for more potential discussion:
An alleged child starvation case near Longview is one of more than a dozen cases -- including one death -- that have state officials reviewing how adopted children are placed and treated.The Governor has appointed a study group to consider these cases and the following questions:
The number of abuse cases is small compared to all adoptions. But a string of high- profile child starvation cases last year -- including one from May accusing Jeffrey and Rebecca Trebilcock of starving their five adopted children at their Bunker Hill-area home in Cowlitz County -- has state officials alarmed.
"Starting in the beginning of 2011 we started seeing a cluster effect of these types of cases," said Mary Meinig, director of the state's Family and Children's Ombudsman office, who included a section about adoption abuse in her annual report, released last week.
* * *
Officials are concerned at the severity of these cases, the apparent spike in them and that so many seem to involve adopted children. The adoption cases are particularly concerning because screening by the state or private adoption agencies should catch unfit parents before children are placed.
Dr. Frances Chalmers, a Mount Vernon pediatrician who consults with DSHS, began to get a "nagging feeling" that something was up and started tracking starvation cases herself. Meinig started doing the same, finding 15 adoption or guardianship cases since 2009 that involved starvation or severe abuse. Eleven of those cases were in 2011.
•Are neglect and abuse -- including withholding food -- on the rise and are they more prevalent in adoptive homes?I think the article does a good job of offering appropriate caveats that correlation doesn't equal causation, of fleshing out the statistics in this small pool of cases, and of explaining the complex issues the study group will be examining. So read the whole thing.
•Did a rapid increase in adoptions let some unfit parents slip through the cracks?
•Does the adoption process itself need to be reworked?
•Does age, race or gender play a role in abuse of adopted children?
Adopted Children Bring Chinese New Year Celebrations With Them
An AP story at the IndyStar about adoption from China and culture:
With its fireworks, family reunions and feasts, Lunar New Year is the longest and most important celebration for millions throughout the world.
For kids adopted from China, it holds special meaning. Lunar New Year makes them mini-ambassadors of a culture they know little about firsthand.
There's no official handbook on how far parents of internationally adopted children should go to celebrate their kids' birth cultures, but marking Lunar New Year -- Year of the Dragon begins Jan. 23 -- is usually one of those times for Asian children.
Their parents decorate front doors, throw dumpling-making parties and stuff red envelopes with money. They clean their homes at the start of the 15-day celebration and hang red lanterns at the end. Others keep it simple, sharing dim sum with friends at a restaurant or watching dragons dance at parades in Chinese enclaves in their communities.
For Myra Cocca in Central Indiana, it's harder as her kids have grown older and busier to observe the traditions they loved when they were small. Her son, adopted from South Korea, is 11 now. When he was little, she dressed him in a traditional garment called a hanbok for the celebration. Today, "sometimes we're not home during the holiday, so we have not always marked the occasion," she said.
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
Right & Wrong Reasons to Adopt
The Kansas State Collegian opines on the right and wrong reasons to adopt:
Our world is currently full of problems that some of the brightest minds on earth have yet to solve. In situations like those, the media and other sources will often turn to the common man for the solution.Reactions? I wonder if the author has considered the right and wrong reasons to give birth -- where would we put "it's cheaper than adoption" on that list?!
Commercials promising to feed a child for a dollar a day or monetary programs to keep an endangered tiger safe are among the most popular uses of this tactic.
Earth’s overpopulation is one of these global issues that the public is called on to help combat through an extreme and personal decision: adoption. However, adopting a child is too important of a process to undertake for any reason except personal aspiration and the desire to change a child’s life. I believe that people have to understand that before they continue with such a monumental decision.
Adoption, much like anything else, can be and is done for completely the wrong reasons.
Some people adopt to claim a boost on their tax income. Other people will choose to adopt to prove a point or to show how “caring” and “loving” they are, without actually having any interest in the children.
I know two children who were adopted and instantly put to work in their new home, and since then have been used as nothing but labor. These corrupt uses of adoption should not overshadow its design, however, and its main purpose to allow children to have a second chance at a normal and productive childhood, which is the best reason for adoption in the first place.
* * *
Here are some things to keep in mind when it comes to adoption: There are many women who turn to adoption because they cannot have their own children, but for couples who are able to have kids, the birthing process is an important step in connecting emotionally with the child. The age of adoption is also important to consider, as well as the cost.
SC Court Accepts Appeal of ICWA Case
If you've been following the story of the 2-year-old, adopted at birth, who was returned to her biological father, the South Carolina Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case at the request of the adoptive parents:
The South Carolina Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case involving a 2-year-old girl whose adoptive parents had to turn her over to her biological father on New Year's Eve.Interesting that the article doesn't mention ICWA at all. I addressed some of the ICWA issues here. It's possible to challenge the adoption on grounds other than ICWA, of course. The birth father's attorney seems to be arguing that the father's consent was involuntary because it was based on misinformation. That's a valid legal ground in adoption law, separate and apart from the ICWA issues.
The (Charleston) Post and Courier reported Monday that Matt and Melanie Capobianca turned over the girl to her biological father, 30-year-old Dusten Brown, an enrolled member of the Cherokee Nation from Oklahoma.
The Capobiancos must file their first briefs by Thursday.
The couple says they adopted the girl when she was born in 2009 from the biological mother. Brown filed for custody four months later.
Brown's attorney argued that the girl's biological mother concealed her plans to put their daughter up for adoption, and that Brown believed he signed his custody rights to the mother.
Monday, January 16, 2012
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Day
I hope you had a good day celebrating the life of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. My kids made a video, giving their own version of the "I have a dream" speech, but wouldn't you know it, I can't get it uploaded! They worked really hard on it, so I'm just sick I can't get my little video recorder to connect to my computer. I'll keep trying, but in the meantime, here's the text of the speech (at least the pepared remarks, slight variations on the video):
Zoom in on sign reading "I have a dream." Zoom out and focus on Zoe and Maya in alternating order. . . .
Zoe: I have a dream that everyone is treated equal [sic!].
Maya: I have a dream that everyone has good shelter.
Zoe: I have a dream that slavery will never happen again.
Maya: I have a dream that everyone has healthy food and clean water.
Zoe: I have a dream that children will not be bullied because of their race.
Maya: I have a dream that every child can grow up to be what they want to be.
Zoe: I have a dream that all bad adoption laws against parents and children will be repealed [we had talked earlier in the day about laws that prevented access to original birth certificates by adoptees and birth parents].
Maya: I have a dream that every adopted child can know their birth parents.
Zoe: I have a dream that all orphans find homes.
Maya: I have a dream that everyone can believe what they want to believe.
Zoe: I have a dream that it doesn't matter where you cme from, because you are just as unique as everyone else, and we all belong to the human family.
Camera zooms in on sign reading "What's your dream?" while voice-over says. . .
Together: What's your dream?
So, how about answering their question in the comments: what's your dream, this MLK day?
Zoom in on sign reading "I have a dream." Zoom out and focus on Zoe and Maya in alternating order. . . .
Zoe: I have a dream that everyone is treated equal [sic!].
Maya: I have a dream that everyone has good shelter.
Zoe: I have a dream that slavery will never happen again.
Maya: I have a dream that everyone has healthy food and clean water.
Zoe: I have a dream that children will not be bullied because of their race.
Maya: I have a dream that every child can grow up to be what they want to be.
Zoe: I have a dream that all bad adoption laws against parents and children will be repealed [we had talked earlier in the day about laws that prevented access to original birth certificates by adoptees and birth parents].
Maya: I have a dream that every adopted child can know their birth parents.
Zoe: I have a dream that all orphans find homes.
Maya: I have a dream that everyone can believe what they want to believe.
Zoe: I have a dream that it doesn't matter where you cme from, because you are just as unique as everyone else, and we all belong to the human family.
Camera zooms in on sign reading "What's your dream?" while voice-over says. . .
Together: What's your dream?
So, how about answering their question in the comments: what's your dream, this MLK day?
Sunday, January 15, 2012
International Adoption Scam Busted in Mexico
The Daily Mail reports that 11 Irish families were scammed by a child-smuggling ring in Mexico:
Seven Mexican babies have been seized from Irish couples after police in Guadalajara smashed an international child-smuggling ring.In light of that information from the Irish Adoption Authority, I have to say it's hard to believe that the prospective adoptive parents thought they were involved with legitimate international adoption. It took me three seconds to find out the process of international adoption in Ireland on Google.
Officials said the couples believed they were following proper adoption channels but that the babies were actually being sold by their mothers. Up to 11 Irish families
were being questioned this weekend in connection with the scam, centred in the Guadalajara region of central Mexico, where four local women have been arrested.
* * *
Three Mexican women, all aged in their early 30s, were subsequently arrested on suspicion of belonging to a child-trafficking gang.
They are suspected of using newspaper advertisements to find expectant mothers who did not want to keep their babies – then buying the infants from the women and handing them over to wealthy foreign couples who travelled to Mexico seeking to adopt.
The Irish couples were reportedly given the babies at a hotel in Guadalajara and sent to the nearby town of Ajijic, a popular retirement destination for Canadian and American expats, to spend a fortnight with the babies while adoption papers were processed.
The processing was done in the neighbouring state of Colima. It is not clear whether suspected gang members intended faking documents or had corrupt local officials in their pay.
The birth mothers are said to have been paid €70 a week plus medical expenses while they were pregnant.
One local paper reported that after the mothers gave birth, the child-trafficking suspects got them to sign a contract permitting them to ‘hire’ their babies for €30 a day over a fortnight for use in photoshoots for publicity contracts.
Instead, the babies were handed over to the foreign couples and the birth mothers were given a copy of the contract, which they used to justify their babies’ absence to friends and neighbours. Mexican authorities said the Guadalajara-based firm Lopez & Lopez Associates was involved in drawing up those contracts. It is not clear whether the mothers knew their babies would be given up permanently or whether they expected them back after the fortnight.
* * *
As the arrests and investigation unfolded during the past few days, Ireland’s Adoption Authority issued a release on Thursday about intercountry adoptions involving Mexico. The Mexican authorities stated that all documentation must be sent by the ‘Adoption Authority of Ireland, or a body accredited by the AAI, to the Federal Central Authority’ – as per the Mexican notice on the Hague Convention website.
The release also pointed out that Irish visa applicants must clearly state the actual purpose of their visit to Mexico and prospective adoptive parents need to obtain an adoption visa.
‘While some individual States within the Federal United States of Mexico may allow for private domestic adoptions outside public entities, there is no provision for private adoptions in the context of intercountry adoption,’ the release said.
‘No children under five years of age should be proposed for intercountry adoption, the only exceptions being children with special needs or sibling groups.
‘On the basis of the foregoing, prospective adoptive parents should not enter into any private arrangements with private individuals or private agencies.’
Chinese New Year, Performance Edition
Chinese New Year is approaching (January 23), and we've started off the usual round of celebrations with a performance. The Fort Worth Chinese School, where the girls attend, was invited to perform their lion dance and flag dance at a local adoption agency's adoptive families Chinese New Year celebration (not the agency we used, btw). It was kind of interesting attending such an event NOT as audience but as performers!
The girls had a great time showing off, and I'm hopeful that some of the adoptive parents present might think about sending their children to Chinese School!
The girls got to partake of the buffet, with Zoe eating her weight in dumplings, as usual, and do some of the crafts available for the kids. (Yes, that's Maya posing with the fan she colored.)
Afterwards, some of the audience kids posed with the lion masks, to the delight of the adoptive parents. Of course, mine also had to pose -- they're behind these masks (and the ones above) with their good friend Mae.
The girls had a great time showing off, and I'm hopeful that some of the adoptive parents present might think about sending their children to Chinese School!
The girls got to partake of the buffet, with Zoe eating her weight in dumplings, as usual, and do some of the crafts available for the kids. (Yes, that's Maya posing with the fan she colored.)
Afterwards, some of the audience kids posed with the lion masks, to the delight of the adoptive parents. Of course, mine also had to pose -- they're behind these masks (and the ones above) with their good friend Mae.
Saturday, January 14, 2012
For Many Latinos, Racial Identity is More Culture than Color
From the New York Times, an interesting exploration of race versus ethnicity versus culture among Latinos:
Every decade, the Census Bureau spends billions of dollars and deploys hundreds of thousands of workers to get an accurate portrait of the American population. Among the questions on the census form is one about race, with 15 choices, including “some other race.”
More than 18 million Latinos checked this “other” box in the 2010 census, up from 14.9 million in 2000. It was an indicator of the sharp disconnect between how Latinos view themselves and how the government wants to count them. Many Latinos argue that the country’s race categories — indeed, the government’s very conception of identity — do not fit them.
The main reason for the split is that the census categorizes people by race, which typically refers to a set of common physical traits. But Latinos, as a group in this country, tend to identify themselves more by their ethnicity, meaning a shared set of cultural traits, like language or customs.
Orphan still fighting effects of Vietnam War
From the BBC, a story about one of the Vietnam babylift orphans (still called an orphan in the headline after adoption decades before?!):
Lê Thanh is 40 this year. At least, he thinks he is.
His birthday was given to him by a Rhondda dentist after the Welsh family who adopted him at the end of the Vietnam War tried to establish his age through dental testing.
He doesn't know anything about his background - he was just told that when he was taken to an orphanage, he was well nourished, suggesting his family had cared for him before they were possibly killed.
Even his full Vietnamese name Lê Thanh Hung was lost in the confusion of his adoption. He now just goes by the complete name Lê Thanh, without a surname.
Apart from these few details and a photo of him clutching a doll at his orphanage, very little of his life as a toddler is known.
* * *
"Growing up in the Rhondda in the 1970s was obviously very difficult as there were no other Oriental people growing up in that area at that time," said Lê Thanh, who was adopted by a vicar and a health visitor from Penygraig and was brought up with their two other children.
"I was bullied by the school bully but I stood my ground. My philosophy is what doesn't kill you makes you stronger.
"But I didn't really have a happy childhood. It wasn't impoverished but I have always been different and I never really fitted in. Even in today's society I still don't really fit in."
* * *
"I now co-ordinate reunions of fellow adoptees and although I mark it as a social reunion, the true reason behind it for a lot of people like myself, with my background, is that they're very much displaced," he said.
"They are still very much uncomfortable in their own skins and have their issues.
"Lots of people who went through this [being adopted] thought they were the only ones. The reunions let us connect and share experiences and feelings."
Friday, January 13, 2012
Children of Haiti: 2 Years Later
CBSThisMorning did a piece on Haiti and adoption today. Watch the 6.33 minute video above, or read at this link. Here's an excerpt:
Hill shared the story of a couple from Ohio, Jon and Julie Kraner, who want to adopt a child but face challenges with the process [they've only been married 2 years, Haiti requires 10 years].
The new head of Haiti's social services agency, Arielle Jeanty, is trying to turn things around in the country. But she doesn't see international adoption as the answer, calling it "the last option" for these children.
Jeanty has two major concerns: Child-trafficking, and also the future of this country -- if the children leave, who will lead Haiti into its next chapter?
Even before the earthquake, Haiti was the poorest country in the Western hemisphere. There is no free public education and barely half of the adult population can read. There are few social services. For many, daily life is simply a game of survival. And since the quake, it's only gotten worse.
Thursday, January 12, 2012
"Where would I sit on the bus, mommy?"
I've mentioned before that each year around Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Day my kids always have tons of questions about race, racism and Jim Crow. They learn about the black/white divide of MLK's time, and wonder where they fit with that duality. Usually, they're learning about Rosa Parks and the question has been about where they would sit on the bus. Today, the questioner was Maya, and the first question was about why the KKK burned crosses on black people's lawns. She wanted to know if that sort of thing still happened, and I had to tell her it did, but not as often. She asked if "they" would have burned a cross on her lawn "back then," since she is "kind of a little dark." Lots to unpack there, hmmm?
If you have Asian children and are getting similar questions this time of year, you might want to check out a previous post, Asian Americans, Adoption and Jim Crow.
If you have Asian children and are getting similar questions this time of year, you might want to check out a previous post, Asian Americans, Adoption and Jim Crow.
Biggest Misperception of UNICEF
At the Council on Foreign Relations, Dr. Susan Bissell, Associate Director and Programmes Chief Child Protection, UNICEF, answers questions, including "What is the biggest misperception of UNICEF?"
The biggest misperception is that UNICEF is against inter-country adoption. We are most certainly not against inter-country adoption. I think that there is some very deliberate and misleading journalism in this area. We support the continuum of care: everything from trying to support vulnerable families so they don’t have to relinquish their children; to permanent foster care; to having a child with his or her extended family on a permanent basis; to transparent and ethical inter-country adoption. We are guided by international standards like the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. It is saddening and it is personal. There is so much written about what my colleagues and I are trying to do in the field to fix these problems, and I think we’re making progress on addressing this misperception.I've addressed this common misperception about UNICEF here and here and here. Though Dr. Bissell thinks they're making progress on addressing the misperception, I'd have to say the UNICEF blame game in the adoptive parent community is as strong as ever.
Wednesday, January 11, 2012
Artyom Finally Finds New Home
The Shelbyville (TN) Times-Gazette reports:
I'm not saying this is a bad thing for Artyom. Obviously, family-like care is better than institutional care, even if it is not a permanent family (and 17 children sounds more like a group home than foster care). I just think it's an overstatement to say in the headline that he has a new adoptive family. And the distinction will make a difference in the lawsuit against Torrey Hansen for child support for Artyom. If he's been legally adopted, her child support obligations for the future would end, though she would still be obligated for the payments between her adoption and the termination of her parental rights in a new adoption.
Artyom Savelyev, the boy sent back to Russia by his adopted mother from Shelbyville in 2010, has finally found a home.The newspaper's headline says this is a new adoptive family; the story doesn't mention the legalities of adoption, and SOS Villages are generally temporary foster care. Nothing on the SOS Villages Russia website suggests differently, instead saying:
According to the Russian State News agency RIA Novosti, the 9-year-old has joined 16 other children who are being cared for by a woman that has raised several generations of abandoned children.
In April 2010 Nancy Hansen placed the boy, who had been known as Justin Hansen while living in the United States, on a flight back to Moscow with a note from her daughter Torry, his adoptive mother, saying she no longer wanted to keep him because he was violent and had severe "psychopathic" problems. The case sparked outrage and an international incident.
But nearly two years after being sent back to his homeland, Artyom is now living in an SOS Children's Village in Russia, cared for by teacher Vera Yegorova.
* * *
"Counting Artyom, I have 17 children," Yegorova told RIA Novosti. "He is so exhausted by plane flights and going back and forth between orphanages and parents," she was quoted as saying.
Artyom was accepted as a family member "in no time at all," the state news media outlet stated, and made friends with the other children. He started attending school, likes it there, and is bringing home his first good grades. The boy is reportedly very respectful of his adoptive parents, calling Yegorova 'mom' on the second day.
However, RIA Novosti states that Artyom "is still afraid of leaving the village," explaining that nothing can lure him away.
"He never deviates from one path -- the one leading from home to school and back. But he is fond of village life as it is. He is reluctant to recall his past experiences in America and says he has turned over a new leaf," the story from RIA Novosti stated.
Yegorova said they learned from the media that Artyom lived in America, but that the child "said nothing about that. He even claimed that he knew no English when we were buying textbooks for school," she said.
SOS Children’s Villages Russia is an independent non-governmental organization that provides a family approach to the long term care of orphaned and abandoned children. We bring orphaned children back to the natural atmosphere of the family giving them back a mother (an SOS-mother), a home and a happy childhood in a supportive Village environment.(There is a section of the website that talks about SOS Villages strengthening families, but it doesn't sound like that's what this is -- hard to tell since the full explanation of what that part of the program does is only in Russian!)
I'm not saying this is a bad thing for Artyom. Obviously, family-like care is better than institutional care, even if it is not a permanent family (and 17 children sounds more like a group home than foster care). I just think it's an overstatement to say in the headline that he has a new adoptive family. And the distinction will make a difference in the lawsuit against Torrey Hansen for child support for Artyom. If he's been legally adopted, her child support obligations for the future would end, though she would still be obligated for the payments between her adoption and the termination of her parental rights in a new adoption.
Tuesday, January 10, 2012
The Existing Indian Family Doctrine
There are obviously strong feelings in a difficult case, like the one I posted about, where a child who spent 2 years with adoptive parents is returned to birth parents. I wanted to address one issue raised in the comments by various commenters, touching on the Indian Child Welfare Act aspect of the case:
Under the existing Indian family doctrine, courts would take one of two approaches. In a case of newborn adoption, the court would say, "The child was never part of an existing Indian family," emphasizing that the child hadn't lived with the birth parents as a family. Right, because the child was never ALLOWED to be part of an existing Indian family! I especially like that argument in cases where the Native American parent, usually the birth father, was never told about the existence of the child or given notice of the adoption, much less the opportunity to bring the child into an existing Indian family.
And as I mentioned, there's nothing in ICWA that requires an existing Indian family -- only that it be a child custody case involving an Indian child as defined in the act. An Indian child is "any unmarried person who is under age eighteen and is either (a) a member of an Indian tribe or (b) is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and is the biological child of a member of an Indian tribe."
There's a pretty clear reason why ICWA doesn't include the phrase "existing Indian family" -- the intent of ICWA is not simply to protect Indian families, but to protect the sovereignty of Indian tribes and to protect Indian children, separate and apart from whether their families are existing Indian families. The creation of the "existing Indian family" is some of that judicial activism that it's so popular to rail against these days.
The second way courts have used the "existing Indian family" doctrine is to focus on the Indian part, and deny application of ICWA if the court feels the birth parent isn't "Indian" enough. Like in a California case where the court noted that the birth parents didn't live on the reservation, didn't participate in tribal events, did not have Indian artifacts in their homes, and did not follow Indian traditions and holidays at home.
I find this particular use of "existing Indian family" doctrine particularly troubling. Here we have white courts making judgments about what it means to be Native American. With little knowlege of what it actually means to be Native American, courts focus on outward trappings, and tend to do so with stereotypical notions of Indianness. Does he wear braids? Do they have a dream catcher over the crib? Do they have a peace pipe at home? Yikes, how offensive is that! And the whole point of ICWA was to avoid this kind of prejudiced thinking by non-Indian courts.
Can you imagine doing that with any other racial or ethnic group? "You're African-American, but you shouldn't be allowed to adopt an African-American child, because you don't live in the inner city, you don't speak Ebonics, you don't listen to rap. You don't qualify as an existing African-American family." China gives a preference in adoption to ethnically-Chinese parents -- what if they said, "What? You don't celebrate Grave Sweeping Day? You can't use chopsticks? You didn't hang Spring Couplets above your door last Lunar New Year? You don't qualify as an existing Chinese family!" Would we be ok with that?
ICWA is designed to prevent outsiders from deciding who is Indian -- the act gives the responsibility to the tribes themselves to decide who is a tribal member, and then hinges all of ICWA's protection from that definition. The existing Indian family doctrine is completely contrary to ICWA.
And courts have come to recognize that. Kansas, the state that invented the existing Indian family exception to ICWA, has now rejected it. And Kansas isn't alone -- 13 of the 19 states that once followed the doctrine have since rejected it as contrary to the language of the statute. That leaves only 6 states that still follow it, and two of those states have limited the existing Indian family doctrine considerably.
The pendulum is swinging back so that the actual language of ICWA will prevail, not the judicially invented "existing Indian family" doctrine. If folks think the existing Indian family doctrine should prevail, they first have to change the statute. Without that, courts are not mis-applying the law in cases like this one.
"the indian law being used here is silly. he is not an active part of the indian community."I think the commenters are alluding to something called the "existing Indian family" doctrine, that some state courts have adopted in applying ICWA. That phrase does not exist in the statute, having been invented 4 years after the adoption of ICWA by a Kansas court seeking not to apply the federal statute to an adoption case. As we say in law, hard facts make bad law. And these days, only 6 states are still following that doctrine.
"Apparently he does not live within the tribe, so it's doubtful this child will grow up knowing her 'tribe' or any of it's true purposes."
"just because someone is an enrolled member of the tribe, as this dad is, doesn't necessarily mean grew up with the tribe, that he lives with the tribe now, or that he participates in the affairs the tribe in any meaningful way."
Under the existing Indian family doctrine, courts would take one of two approaches. In a case of newborn adoption, the court would say, "The child was never part of an existing Indian family," emphasizing that the child hadn't lived with the birth parents as a family. Right, because the child was never ALLOWED to be part of an existing Indian family! I especially like that argument in cases where the Native American parent, usually the birth father, was never told about the existence of the child or given notice of the adoption, much less the opportunity to bring the child into an existing Indian family.
And as I mentioned, there's nothing in ICWA that requires an existing Indian family -- only that it be a child custody case involving an Indian child as defined in the act. An Indian child is "any unmarried person who is under age eighteen and is either (a) a member of an Indian tribe or (b) is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and is the biological child of a member of an Indian tribe."
There's a pretty clear reason why ICWA doesn't include the phrase "existing Indian family" -- the intent of ICWA is not simply to protect Indian families, but to protect the sovereignty of Indian tribes and to protect Indian children, separate and apart from whether their families are existing Indian families. The creation of the "existing Indian family" is some of that judicial activism that it's so popular to rail against these days.
The second way courts have used the "existing Indian family" doctrine is to focus on the Indian part, and deny application of ICWA if the court feels the birth parent isn't "Indian" enough. Like in a California case where the court noted that the birth parents didn't live on the reservation, didn't participate in tribal events, did not have Indian artifacts in their homes, and did not follow Indian traditions and holidays at home.
I find this particular use of "existing Indian family" doctrine particularly troubling. Here we have white courts making judgments about what it means to be Native American. With little knowlege of what it actually means to be Native American, courts focus on outward trappings, and tend to do so with stereotypical notions of Indianness. Does he wear braids? Do they have a dream catcher over the crib? Do they have a peace pipe at home? Yikes, how offensive is that! And the whole point of ICWA was to avoid this kind of prejudiced thinking by non-Indian courts.
Can you imagine doing that with any other racial or ethnic group? "You're African-American, but you shouldn't be allowed to adopt an African-American child, because you don't live in the inner city, you don't speak Ebonics, you don't listen to rap. You don't qualify as an existing African-American family." China gives a preference in adoption to ethnically-Chinese parents -- what if they said, "What? You don't celebrate Grave Sweeping Day? You can't use chopsticks? You didn't hang Spring Couplets above your door last Lunar New Year? You don't qualify as an existing Chinese family!" Would we be ok with that?
ICWA is designed to prevent outsiders from deciding who is Indian -- the act gives the responsibility to the tribes themselves to decide who is a tribal member, and then hinges all of ICWA's protection from that definition. The existing Indian family doctrine is completely contrary to ICWA.
And courts have come to recognize that. Kansas, the state that invented the existing Indian family exception to ICWA, has now rejected it. And Kansas isn't alone -- 13 of the 19 states that once followed the doctrine have since rejected it as contrary to the language of the statute. That leaves only 6 states that still follow it, and two of those states have limited the existing Indian family doctrine considerably.
The pendulum is swinging back so that the actual language of ICWA will prevail, not the judicially invented "existing Indian family" doctrine. If folks think the existing Indian family doctrine should prevail, they first have to change the statute. Without that, courts are not mis-applying the law in cases like this one.
Monday, January 9, 2012
Birth Father Wins Adoption Battle
CNN reports on the role of the Indian Child Welfare Act in the return of 2-year-old Veronica to her birth father, after the adoptive parents' failure to follow that federal law:
For the first few moments of her life, Veronica was with her birth mother.
For the next two years, she was with her adoptive parents.
And for the last week, the toddler has been with her biological father, over 1,000 miles away from the only home she'd ever known.
It's been a long, complicated journey for young Veronica -- one made possible by a federal law meant "to protect the best interests of Indian children" that, in the process, has tugged at the heartstrings of all involved.
The story began in 2009, when Veronica's biological mother and father, Dusten Brown, signed a legal document agreeing to put the girl up for adoption. Brown's attorney, Shannon Jones, says that her client signed the waiver but didn't quite understand it.
Soon after the girl was born, Brown -- a U.S. Army soldier -- headed off on a 1-year deployment.
It was then that the baby moved on as well, to the Charleston, South Carolina, home of Matt and Melanie Capobianco.
It was an open adoption, family friend Jessica Munday said. That meant the girl's birth mother could and did maintain a relationship with the girl.It's a pretty unusual case, in that birth fathers rarely win in adoption revocations. One really important fact to note by all of those who decry the removal of the child after two years with her adoptive parents -- those parents have known since she was 4 months old that the birth father was seeking to reverse the adoption. I expect they were playing the delay game, which, as I posted here, usually benefits the adoptive parent in possession. Now the adoptive parents are saying they will appeal, and the benefit of delay belongs to the birth father. . . .
But Brown, the biological father, wasn't on board. Four months after Veronica's birth, he began legal proceedings seeking custody of her.
"My client has been fighting for custody of his daughter since shortly after her birth," Shannon Jones, Brown's Charleston-based lawyer, said by e-mail. "He loves this child with all his heart."
Brown appeared to win that battle late last year. On New Year's Eve, he arrived in South Carolina, picked up Veronica from her adoptive parents, and headed west to his home in Oklahoma.
Rock Center: Haitian Adoption Story Tonight
NBC's Rock Center is doing a report tonight about adoption after the earthquake in Haiti. I won't have a chance to catch it, but wanted to give folks a head's up. Here's an intro from their website, by correspondent Ron Allen:
It doesn't happen often, but sometimes a chance encounter can lead to a story that continues for a couple of years.
I hadn't been on the ground in Haiti for long after the earthquake-- which struck two years ago on Jan. 12, 2010 -- when a producer handed me a piece of paper with a name and phone number on it. Brian Williams had met a young pastor on a flight out of Port Au Prince, who had literally begged him for help. There were about 50 children in a life or death situation. They had survived the quake and been evacuated to a makeshift shelter, where food and water were running out. They were getting little help, because there was so much tragedy and mayhem everywhere.
What's more, many of the children were in the process of being adopted by American families. Some of those parents had flown to Haiti and were desperately trying to get their "almost-adopted" kids out.
All of this hit me at a deeply personal level. My 3-year-old daughter Siobhan was born in Ethiopia. We adopted her when she was just a few months old. I've spent a lot of years covering conflicts and disasters around the world and I've always been struck by the countless number of children I've seen living in such desperate circumstances. I didn't go looking for this story in Haiti, somehow it found me. It all felt a bit odd at first, and so close. But after mulling all of this with a few colleagues, I pressed on. And I'm glad I did.
Anti-Huntsman Ad Hits Home for Adoptive Families
This is the first piece I've seen addressing adoptive parents' reaction to the anti-Huntsman video I posted:
Presidential politics hit home for an Alexandria family on Friday after a web ad aimed at Republican candidate Jon Huntsman raised questions about his values, citing his ability to speak Chinese and his decision to adopt children from China and India. The ad, sponsored by a group identified as NYLiberty4Paul, urges voters to support Texas Congressman Ron Paul in the race, though Paul disavowed the ad and said his campaign had nothing to do with it.Any local reporting of this in your area? Interesting response from the mom -- it's "a highly American thing" to adopt children anywhere in the world? Of course, folks from other countries do the same thing! And you could really turn that one on its head, too: international adoption can be criticized as neo-colonial, imperialistic depradation of the so-called third world by the Western world, including America. So in that way, international adoption is a "highly American thing" to do!
"It's a very strange way to make a point," said Alexandria lawyer Nancy Jo Nelson, who has adopted three girls from China.
"I think there is nothing more American than adopting a child that has been abandoned anywhere in the world. It's a highly American thing to do," she said.
Saturday, January 7, 2012
Connecting to Culture Through Food
The Indianapolis Star has an article about adoptive parents connecting to adopted children's home cultures through food, with lots of anecdotes and this reminder:
I know my kids love Chinese food. For special occasions like birthdays and adoption days, where they are given unfettered choice of restaurants, Zoe ALWAYS picks Chinese. She definitely connects it to her heritage, wanting it especially on those trigger days that remind her of birth parents and heritage. It's not the only time we eat Chinese, but we inevitably do on those days.
So eating ethnic food won't quite get you there, but it is an easy place to start in most areas where ethnic grocery stores make the ingredients easy to get and ethnic restaurants are abundant. Just don't stop there. . . .
Families who adopt internationally often try to keep a child's heritage alive by playing music from that country, buying indigenous clothing or gifts or trying to master the child's birth language.Of course, food is a good place to start with culture-keeping, but it isn't the end of it. Remember the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute's report, Beyond Culture Camp: "Positive racial/ethnic identity development is most effectively facilitated by “lived” experiences such as travel to native country, attending racially diverse schools, and having role models of their own race/ethnicity." In that report, 84% of Korean adoptees said that they had dined in Korean restaurants or eaten Korean food, but only 68% said it was helpful in forming a positive racial/ethnic identity. Still, that ranked higher in helpfulness than did having a Korean doll/traditional object (49%), or studying traditional dance or martial arts (38%).
It's critical not to ignore the child's ties to another culture, said Nancy Janus, an associate professor of human development at Eckerd College in St. Petersburg, Fla., who has researched international adoptions and has three daughters adopted from Colombia.
"That's unquestionable, because it's who the kids are," Janus said. "It's especially relevant where there's no racial similarity. . . . There's a need to understand their differentness."
Food offers one avenue for adoptive families.
I know my kids love Chinese food. For special occasions like birthdays and adoption days, where they are given unfettered choice of restaurants, Zoe ALWAYS picks Chinese. She definitely connects it to her heritage, wanting it especially on those trigger days that remind her of birth parents and heritage. It's not the only time we eat Chinese, but we inevitably do on those days.
So eating ethnic food won't quite get you there, but it is an easy place to start in most areas where ethnic grocery stores make the ingredients easy to get and ethnic restaurants are abundant. Just don't stop there. . . .
Friday, January 6, 2012
Huntsman responds to video
Here's Jon Huntsman's response to the video claiming him to be some kind of Manchurian candidate for speaking Chinese and having adopted a child from China and a child from India:
Speaking before the College Convention, Huntsman was asked about the spot, which features him in Chairman Mao garb, and questions whether the former U.S. Ambassador to China values "American values, or Chinese" and implies that he would be weak on China.
"I saw just parts of it yesterday," he said. "First of all, it is just stupid. Second of all, yeah, I lived overseas four times ... I speak Chinese, of course I do. If someone wants to poke fun of me for speaking Chinese, that's okay. The thing I object to is bringing forward pictures and videos of my adopted daughters and suggesting that there is some sinister motive there. I have a daughter from China who was abandoned at two months of age and left in a vegetable market, picked up by the police and sent to an orphanage."
"I have a second daughter who was born in India in a very rural village ... and left for dead the day she was born," he added. "And luckily she was picked up before the animals got her, and she was sent to an orphanage for her safety, was raised and now she is in my family. So I have two little girls who are a daily reminder that there are a lot of kids in this world who don't have the breaks that you do and face a very uncertain future ... and now these two girls are on the presidential campaign trail. I say, how cool is that?"What do you think of the response? I certainly agree with his "it is just stupid" characterization of the video. But the description of his adopted children's beginnings? Not so much. A little too much rescue-a-poor-pitiful-orphan for me. . . .
Adoption from China Incompatible with American Values?
Lord, what a bizarre video! Thanks to Reena, who linked to it in the comments to the De-Americanizing Asian Americans post, we can see what at least one crazy person (the video-maker) thinks of the fact that Jon Huntsman can speak Chinese and has adopted a daughter from China! Suddenly it makes him the Manchurian candidate, it makes him Mao, it makes him not-American. Sheesh!
FYI, I have no dog in the Republican primary fight. This is not meant as endorsement or condemnation of any candidate! But I will say I'm completely jealous of Huntsman's fluency in Chinese. . . .
Competitive Adoption Mothering
Does this comment from Terra Trevor, author of Pushing Up the Sky, ring true?
We had (and still have) a close group of friends who waited together to adopt from China, and all adopted within a few months of each other, with all the children aged within months of each other. At one of our first big get-togethers after we'd all returned, one of the moms did the "look why my child can do" thing, and adorable baby could point to parts of her body as mom asked, "Where's your nose? Where's your mouth?"
Zoe couldn't do those things (none of the other girls could, either!) It hadn't even occurred to me to teach her those things. I was still so exhausted with the oh-so-new day-to-day parenting job that it was a miracle we'd even made it to the party clean and clothed!
But by our next get-together? Zoe could identify a bazillion body parts! And so could all the other girls!
Most of all, I'm wondering, when did writing about motherhood get to be so complicated? Toss in adoption. The home study process with its series of self-studies focusing on our ideas regarding parenting and our child rearing philosophy gear us toward extreme self-improvement. This is where the rubber meets the road, particularly in International and transracial adoption. It's the juncture where a fire is lit in us to question our values, and often this process leads some of us to judge others whose models do not match our own.I remember my very first competitive mothering moment. . . .
We accept the need to put extra effort into adoption mothering. We read everything we can get our hands on about adoption. We participate in adoption conferences, email group discussions, and support groups. In this setting, is it little wonder that in our eagerness to become enlightened, in our sincere desire to better ourselves, that we have a tendency to become overly critical?
For as long as I have been a mother which began on a joyful day in 1981, one thing has remained a constant. Within our sisterhood of adoptive mothers, we are a bit hard on each other. Comparisons are constantly made, and someone always draws the short straw. Perhaps it's because the adoption process with its long wait list to be matched with a child drives us to be competitive.
We had (and still have) a close group of friends who waited together to adopt from China, and all adopted within a few months of each other, with all the children aged within months of each other. At one of our first big get-togethers after we'd all returned, one of the moms did the "look why my child can do" thing, and adorable baby could point to parts of her body as mom asked, "Where's your nose? Where's your mouth?"
Zoe couldn't do those things (none of the other girls could, either!) It hadn't even occurred to me to teach her those things. I was still so exhausted with the oh-so-new day-to-day parenting job that it was a miracle we'd even made it to the party clean and clothed!
But by our next get-together? Zoe could identify a bazillion body parts! And so could all the other girls!
Thursday, January 5, 2012
It Came from CyberSpace: An Epidemic of Epic Proportions!
The headlines are alarming: "threat to adopted children;" "lives turned upside down;" "adopted kids at risk." So what's so scary? Why, birth parents, of course! Or maybe it's facebook. . . . Or maybe it's birth parents on facebook. Or maybe what's so scary . . . is the truth our kids deserve.
There are a slew of articles out of England today about the scourge of birth parents contacting adopted children on social media:
Social media threat to adopted children grows in UK -- Reuters
Hundreds of children adopted after being abused have lives turned upside down as natural parents use Facebook to track them down -- [yes, that's a headline!] the Daily Mail
Adopted kids at risk from Facebook -- the Sun
Facebook allows natural parents to track down adopted children, charities warn --the Telegraph
OK, laying aside this popular meme of predatory birth parents stalking their children on social media for a moment, just how serious is this "growing" problem? What evidence is there that HUNDREDS of adopted children have been contacted in this way, much less contacted to negative effect?
According to the Reuters article, "some birth parents" are contacting "some children" and tearing apart "some families." This is as specific as they'll get:
It is not known how many birth parents are using social networking sites to get around this, but the BAAF said it was receiving "more and more cases."Well, then, since the Daily Mail specifically mentions "hundreds of children," they must support it with data, right? Not so much. First, the only hard data point offered is a study about adopted persons contacting birth family, not the other way around:
"We have heard some horror stories, but how frequently it is happening we just don't know," Feast added.
A study by the British Association for Adoption and Fostering found that 53 per cent of adopted children have used unofficial means, such as Facebook, to trace their birth parents. A quarter said that this had been unsettling.OK, I don't mean to completely minimize the potential problem of unexpected birth family contact for an unprepared child of a young age (why they'd then be on facebook is another issue). But if you're going to treat it like an epidemic, shouldn't you have a few more data points?!
The one helpful thing that the articles do offer is advice about preparing children for possible contact, especially if poor parenting choices led to involuntary termination of parental rights. As the Daily Mail says:
Mr Pearce [executive director of AdoptionUK, a support organization for APs] said that it is now necessary to prepare children in advance of possible unplanned contact from their birth parents.
‘Currently adopted children tend to be told a rose-tinted version of what really happened,’ he told The Times.Which is why telling our kids the truth, even hard truths, is the best policy. In an age of social media and other internet content, we can't very well insulate them from all information, and truth will out. So maybe the hysterical nature of these stories will have a salutory effect -- maybe more adoptive parents will see the value of being open and honest with their kids. . . before it's too late (cue the scary music!).
‘Something closer to the truth will better protect and prepare children for the destabilising effects of unplanned contact, which often happens at a key stage in their adolescence.’
How to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, even when it's hard? Here are the Ten Commandments of Telling as a starting point.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









