I was adopted from Colombia. The parents I live with today knew they wanted a little girl, and they also wanted to better someone’s life, so they decided to adopt. One day, they got a phone call about a baby girl in Colombia who had just been born and needed a family. Soon, they were on a plane to Bogota.Hmm, I'm not sure I would have been as understanding if I were in her shoes. . . . To see what happened next, and why the essay is entitled, "It's a Small World," go read the whole thing!
I have lived a completely normal childhood knowing that the people I call Mom and Dad are my “real parents” because I love them and they love me. I never met my birth parents and really didn’t know anything about them until one afternoon when I casually asked my mom if I had any biological siblings that I could contact one day. She gave me a worried look, and then said that she had planned to wait until I was 18 to give me the information, but she thought I was old enough.
My mother explained that I had two biological brothers living in the area and then took out some Christmas cards and letters that one had sent me years ago. The letters contained pictures of my oldest brother when he was four and I couldn’t believe how much of myself I saw in him. My mom told me that she had waited to tell me because she didn’t want me to be confused, but as time passed it got harder since she didn’t want me to think that she was trying to keep a secret. I had to be understanding. My parents never want anything but the best for me - I might have done the same thing.
Tuesday, November 22, 2011
For Teen Adopted from Colombia, it's a Small World
At TeenInk, an essay from a Colombian adoptee about learning about her birth brother:
Monday, November 21, 2011
International Adoptees Take Citizen's Oath
This report from Newsday (subscription/registration required) recounts a citizenship ceremony held recently where international adoptees were sworn in as U.S. citizens (lots of cute pictures, too). This gives me an excuse to post again about the petition at Change.org asking that all international adoptees, even those who have "aged out" under the Child Citizenship Act of 2000, be made citizens.
And check out this post at Transracialeyes, where an adoptive parent asks if it is ever OK not to get U.S. citizenship for an adopted child, like when an older adopted child doesn't want U.S. citizenship. I look forward to reading more comments from adoptees in reply.
And check out this post at Transracialeyes, where an adoptive parent asks if it is ever OK not to get U.S. citizenship for an adopted child, like when an older adopted child doesn't want U.S. citizenship. I look forward to reading more comments from adoptees in reply.
Intercountry Adoption's Mixed Record
Interesting to see RH Reality Check, a website devoted to reproductive & sexual health and justice, tackling this topic:
Most Americans have been touched by adoption and many would agree that inter-country adoption is important and even an embodiment of our nation’s commitment to children and humanitarianism. Since World War Two, approximately one million children have been internationally adopted; leaving their country of origin and placed with adoptive families in other nations. Because US families have received at least 50 percent of these children we have been called an “Adoption Nation.”
* * *
Even with so much good, there has been a dark side to adoption. It is a practice which has more than its fair share of scandals. The 2010 case of the young boy sent back to Russia unaccompanied with nothing more than a note requesting adoption “annulment” is a good example. Then, there was the Russian girl named Masha Allen who was adopted by a pedophile and he proceeded to sell her sexual abuse photo images into Internet pornography. . . .
Other problematic history includes allegations of child abduction. It is hard to forget that during the 2010 aftermath of the Haitian earthquake that a faith or mission group from Idaho attempted to illegally remove or traffic children into the Dominican Republic for the purpose of inter-country adoption. International press eventually identified that most of the children were not ‘orphans’ and their families believed that the children would be cared for and that their families would be able to visit with them and retain relations. When you think about it, families living in extreme poverty could so easily be led to believe such a thing and in a moment of desperation and hope. Allowing your child to leave with a stranger from the U.S. who promises of food and an education may be the only sense of salvation in the moment of disaster chaos. The desperate act eventually plays out as a decision made in haste and with a misrepresentation of intent. Legally such a scenario it fits international child abduction definitions when poor families are unable to retrieve children and then the children enter into adoption schemes.
There have been cases like Cambodia where an American adoption ‘facilitator’ orchestrated child ‘adoptions.’ Rural and mainly illiterate Cambodian families were often given a small sum of money and a bag of rice in exchange for their signature on critical legal documents. Again, these children were not orphans but they were desirable children—relatively young and healthy children who were easily matched with eager US families willing to pay $20,000 or more for the adoption. Investigators found that some of these Cambodian families were led to believe that their children were going to boarding schools overseas. The facilitator was eventually arrested by U.S. Federal Marshalls and she served time in prison for tax evasion, among other charges.
More recently, the most notorious adoption nation with profound problems has been Guatemala. Approximately 30,000 children departed as inter-country adoptees from 1999-2007. Human rights defenders agree that abuses within this system were profound and while there were legitimate adoptions, there were also an unknown number of adoptions with serious irregularities and illegalities. Problems ranged from birth mother payments to induce adoption arrangements to actual child abduction for adoption. . . .
Sadly there are three mothers in Guatemala who have taken to hunger protests for their individual daughters return from the U.S. One of those three women now has a Guatemalan court order for her daughter’s repatriation as a victim of abduction.
Sunday, November 20, 2011
Prescription for the Orphan Crisis
Dr. Jane Aronson's prescription for the orphan crisis, published at CNN, is not adoption:
The U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child states that every child has a right to safety, health and an education, as well as the right to participate fully in family, cultural and social life. The U.S. and the international community must find permanent solutions to address the international orphan crisis. Effective and innovative strategies need to be implemented and more resources must be devoted to preventing child abandonment and helping families to remain intact or to be reunified and reintegrated.I'll say it again: The only way to solve the orphan crisis is to prevent children from becoming orphans in the first place.
Investment in child welfare systems with trained social workers capable of case management in impoverished countries must be the highest priority to strengthen and support families and communities. Families need economic opportunities to make a viable living and social services to help guide them out of poverty. Access to medical care and psychosocial services and universal, free education must be available for all children and their families.
Without such support services, families are more likely to be torn apart by poverty and become victims of depression and hopelessness, which continues the cycle of relinquishment and abandonment. We must figure out how families and communities survive poverty and adversity. What are the intrinsic cultural mechanisms that work in one country and not in another?
Saturday, November 19, 2011
Russia Seeks International Arrest Warrant for American APs Who Killed Russian Boy
From the Washington Post:
The New York Times also reports on the angry reaction of the Russian government to the lenient sentence. The article includes the explanation of the trial judge for the time served sentence:
"Judge Kennedy, in ordering that the couple serve no more jail time, said he did not believe that they posed a danger to the community, or that a stiffer sentence would serve as an example for others. He also said that given their ages — Mr. Craver is 47 and Mrs. Craver is 56 — he did not believe they would become parents again."
Of course, they are already parents of another child -- the twin of the boy they were convicted of killing. The judge also refused prosecutors' request that he order that the Cravers have no unsupervised contact with her until she turns 18, but the judge said he would leave such decisions to child welfare officials.
Nov. 29, 2011: As predicted, this isn't going anywhere! Russian court rules against issue of arrest warrant for Michael, Nanette Craver.
Russia will seek tougher punishment for an American couple convicted in the U.S. of the involuntary manslaughter of a 7-year-old boy they adopted from the country, authorities said Saturday.Hmmm, can't say I expect much to come of this (lots of difficulties in prosecuting crimes that occur outside your borders and committed by non-citizens even if the victim is a citizen of Russia), but 19 months for involuntary manslaughter (meaning a reckless or grossly negligent killing) of a child seems pretty low. . . .
Michael and Nanette Craver of York County in Pennsylvania were sentenced Friday to the 19 months they have already spent in prison for the 2009 head-injury death of their adopted son Nathaniel, formerly Ivan Skorobogatov.
Russia’s federal Investigative Committee said in a statement it will seek an international arrest warrant for the Cravers and prove that the murder was brutal and premeditated.
“That’s the opinion the prosecutors in the U.S. court stick to, and the Investigative Committee fully shares it,” according to the statement from the country’s top investigative body.
Prosecutors had argued that the boy died from repeated blows to the head, but offered no theory at trial about which parent delivered them.
The Cravers insist the boy suffered from fetal alcohol syndrome and attachment disorders. They claimed he ran headlong into a stove the night before they found him unconscious.
The New York Times also reports on the angry reaction of the Russian government to the lenient sentence. The article includes the explanation of the trial judge for the time served sentence:
"Judge Kennedy, in ordering that the couple serve no more jail time, said he did not believe that they posed a danger to the community, or that a stiffer sentence would serve as an example for others. He also said that given their ages — Mr. Craver is 47 and Mrs. Craver is 56 — he did not believe they would become parents again."
Of course, they are already parents of another child -- the twin of the boy they were convicted of killing. The judge also refused prosecutors' request that he order that the Cravers have no unsupervised contact with her until she turns 18, but the judge said he would leave such decisions to child welfare officials.
Nov. 29, 2011: As predicted, this isn't going anywhere! Russian court rules against issue of arrest warrant for Michael, Nanette Craver.
Friday, November 18, 2011
Love is NOT Colorblind
At the Livesay[Haiti]weblog, an exploration of that troublesome phrase, "Love is colorblind." It's a long and important post, so you should go read the whole thing, but I find THIS paragraph to be THE point:
When your adopted minority child looks in the mirror he/she sees black, brown, peach, yellow, tan, etc. skin looking back. For that child to hear us say that our love is “colorblind” can be far more hurtful than any of us would dream. What we mean is that our love for them transcends color and ethnicity. But what they often hear is “I don’t see part of you.” We so desperately want to affirm our children in the security of our unconditional love that we miss the point. What if Tara came to me tomorrow and said, “Amie, I’m going to overlook the fact that you are a red-headed freckle factory and continue loving you anyway”? Besides how completely ironic that would be given our shared features, it would also hurt me deeply because the very nature of such a statement implies that my traits are unbecoming and undesirable and something to be overlooked in order to find me acceptable. Our children want to be accepted because of who they are –inside and out- not in spite of it.YES! This is the same point I was trying to make, though not as eloquently, in the post, Parenting While Not Noticing Race:
You're essentially saying to a child, "I don't think of you as Black or Asian or Latino," when you refuse to acknowledge that race exists. You're denying part of your child. How can that be good?So let's all agree to strike that phrase from our vocabulary. Love is not colorblind. Love sees and revels in ALL colors! As Amie says at the Livesay blog, "Love that overlooks is belittling. Love that acknowledges is accepting." Show your child accepting love, acknowledging love: "I love you because of your race, not in spite of it."
* * *
I just don't get it -- how can parents adopting transracially ignore the race of their children? Do your love your child because of their race or in spite of it? Loving your child because of his or her race is loving ALL of your child, not just some parts of your child. Please love all of your child, including the color of their skin. Please.
Boom-and-Bust Cycles in International Adoption
NPR reports about the downturn in international adoption under a headline that speaks volumes: Fewer Babies Available For Adoption By U.S. Parents. Boy, doesn't that signal the "real" concern -- making sure babies are available for Americans to adopt? And here I thought adoption was about finding families for needy kids, not finding kids for wanting parents. . . .
The article focuses on the boom-and-bust cycle of international adoption from poor countries infected with corruption:
The article focuses on the boom-and-bust cycle of international adoption from poor countries infected with corruption:
Motivated by the desire to provide a home to a needy child, parents . . . don't like to talk about international adoption as a business. But clearly the market forces of supply and demand have been at work.The article also touches on some of the current debates about international adoption:
A country opens its doors to prospective parents, whether because of war, natural disaster, civil strife or chronic poverty. Adoption agencies and their clients rush in, suddenly turning a small country such as Kazakhstan or Nepal into a major exporter of children.
The demand for healthy babies is extremely high among American and European parents, who are willing to spend upwards of $25,000 to $50,000 in fees and travel costs. That kind of money — multiplied many thousands of times over — has led to cases of corruption in many countries.
Numerous countries, including Guatemala and Vietnam, have experienced problems such as judges and lawyers taking bribes, and gangs or even police stealing children. In response to such charges, a nation's government might decide to put a halt to intercountry adoptions, as Romania did a decade ago. Other countries have seen their markets closed, with U.S. or European nations blocking visas for their children, as happened in Nepal.
* * *
Once a country such as Guatemala closes its doors to international adoptions, demand shifts to a new "sending" country such as Ethiopia, and the boom-and-bust cycle repeats itself.
"What we see is a country becoming fashionable," says Susan Jacobs, the State Department's special adviser for children's issues. "People go to the countries where it's easiest to adopt, where the rules are lax and you can do an adoption quickly and perhaps get a baby."
There seems to be a consensus within international child welfare circles that orphans should be kept within their own families or communities whenever possible and adopted domestically if need be.Reactions?
How often international adoptions should be allowed for children who can't find a home in their country of origin, however, is a matter of heated debate.
* * *
Some advocacy groups believe that the best way to improve the lives of needy children is to provide services and support for families in their home countries.
"I don't want to say there's a groundswell, but there is definitely a lot more going on to build up child protective systems than we've ever seen before," says Bissell, of UNICEF. "There's an increased ability of countries to take care of their children and a desire to do so."
But Bissell recognizes that children's services remain underfunded, particularly in the poorest countries.
* * *
Alleviating poverty should be the ultimate goal, Franklin [chairman of the board of the Joint Council on International Children's Services] says, but in the meantime there are millions of orphans around the world who could use a home, many of them in the United States.
"My perception is that it's becoming harder and harder to adopt children while the need is getting bigger," he says.
Thursday, November 17, 2011
Statistics: Intercountry Adoptions Disrupted or Dissolved
The State Department's Annual Report on Adoption includes statistics about disrupted adoptions:
Second, the report won't report an adoption dissolution until a court has legally ended the adoption. The 2010 report notes, for example, that Artyom's case, where the adoption was finalized in Russia and then his mother returned him, is not included in the disruption statistics because no court had yet to legally dissolve the adoption. But, of course, the only reason the State Department knows about Artyom's case is that it was "widely reported," as they put it. Post-adoption, it might be that the agency would never know about it to report it, and the federal government would never know about it because the child has already acquired citizenship. And readoption or foster placement is just a domestic adoption/family law matter that flies under the radar of the State Department.
Third, though the number is small (5), it represents an increase over the 2010 report and the 2009 report, where there were no reported disruptions. Whether that represents an increase in disruptions or an increase in reporting can't be known from the reports.
The second set of statistics is still small -- 33 cases of disruption or dissolution involving 41 children -- out of 9,320 total adoptions in FY 2011. And the pool is likely to be actually larger, since the cases of disruption are captured here regardless of when the adoption happened. Still, it is a disturbing figure. According to the report,
Second, this also represents an increase over 2010, where there were 9 cases representing 22 children. The 2009 report did not include this category.
In FY 2011, adoption service providers (ASPs) reported five disrupted placements in Convention adoptions, i.e., cases in which there was an interruption of a placement for adoption during the post-placement (but pre-adoption) period. Table 6 summarizes this information.First, note that the figures for adoptions from Hague Convention countries are only those reported by an agency. Second, note that the disruption figures apply ONLY to cases where the disruption happened prior to finalization of adoption. That's a pretty small pool, since most international adoptions are finalized in the foreign country, before the child comes to the U.S. That explains why the only countries represented on the list of disruptions are the Philippines and India, two countries where the adoption is not finalized until the child is in the U.S. So a child whose adoption was finalized in China, for instance, and then after coming to the U.S. the adoption was disrupted or dissolved, won't appear in these statistics.
In addition, information received from the Department of Health and Human Services pursuant to §422(b)(12) of the Social Security Act indicated 33 cases of disruptions and dissolutions involving 41 children who were adopted from other countries and entered state custody as a result.
Second, the report won't report an adoption dissolution until a court has legally ended the adoption. The 2010 report notes, for example, that Artyom's case, where the adoption was finalized in Russia and then his mother returned him, is not included in the disruption statistics because no court had yet to legally dissolve the adoption. But, of course, the only reason the State Department knows about Artyom's case is that it was "widely reported," as they put it. Post-adoption, it might be that the agency would never know about it to report it, and the federal government would never know about it because the child has already acquired citizenship. And readoption or foster placement is just a domestic adoption/family law matter that flies under the radar of the State Department.
Third, though the number is small (5), it represents an increase over the 2010 report and the 2009 report, where there were no reported disruptions. Whether that represents an increase in disruptions or an increase in reporting can't be known from the reports.
The second set of statistics is still small -- 33 cases of disruption or dissolution involving 41 children -- out of 9,320 total adoptions in FY 2011. And the pool is likely to be actually larger, since the cases of disruption are captured here regardless of when the adoption happened. Still, it is a disturbing figure. According to the report,
This information was provided in the annual update from states on progress made toward accomplishing goals and objectives in the Child and Family Services Plan. This information was submitted by states to the Department of Health and Human Services through an Annual Progress and Services Report (APSR). The most recent APSRs were submitted on June 30, 2011 and contained information from FY 2010. All of the information provided by states in the APSR was included in this count regardless of the date provided from the states on specific actions taken in a case or when it was reported to the state.First, this statistic is unlikely to reflect the full picture. A child who did not end up in state custody after disruption won't appear in this statistic, either. And it's common for a child from a disrupted adoption to simply be passed on to a new family without entering state custody.
Second, this also represents an increase over 2010, where there were 9 cases representing 22 children. The 2009 report did not include this category.
Intercountry Adoptions to U.S. Down Again
The State Department's Annual Report of adoption statistics is out. As the AP reports, intercountry adoption has hit a new low, and the reason is, at least in part, corruption in adoption:
The number of foreign children adopted by Americans fell by 15 percent last year, reaching the lowest level since 1994 due largely to sharp cutbacks by China and Ethiopia, sources of most adoptees in recent years.
Figures released Tuesday by the State Department for the 2011 fiscal year showed 9,320 adoptions from abroad, down from 11,059 in 2010 and down nearly 60 percent from the all-time peak of 22,884 in 2004.
Once again, China accounted for the most children adopted in the U.S. But its total of 2,589 was down from 3,401 the previous year as China finds itself with fewer abandoned children and more interest in domestic adoptions.
Ethiopia was second, at 1,727 — but that was down from 2,513 in 2010. The main factor was a decision by Ethiopian authorities to slow down the handling of adoption applications to reduce instances of fraud and ease a heavy workload at Ethiopia's youth ministry.
Following Ethiopia on the list were Russia, which accounted for 970 adoptions, South Korea at 736, Ukraine at 632, the Philippines at 230, India at 228, Colombia at 216, Uganda at 207 and Taiwan at 205.
One reason that the overall adoption numbers have dropped so sharply in recent years is that problems of fraud and corruption prompted the U.S. — as well as other nations — to suspend adoptions from several countries, notably Vietnam, Cambodia, Guatemala and Nepal.
Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Harvard Prof: Orphanage Care Stunts Brain Development
The article doesn't say whether this is new research, but it's about adoption/orphan care so I share it -- Harvard prof says orphanage care in Romania negatively affects brain & physical development of children:
Lack of stimulation in Romanian orphanages stunts brain development in children, Harvard Medical School Professor of Pediatrics Charles A. Nelson said at a Harvard China Care event Tuesday evening.About the only thing I hadn't heard before was this: "According to the study, girls do not suffer in institutions as much as boys. Girls also benefit more when they are placed in foster home." Anyone have information on why orphanage/family care differs in effect on boys and girls?
At the request of the Romanian government, Nelson studied the influence of childhood experience and early psycho-social deprivation on the brain in Romanian orphanages.
“Romania had a particularly egregious history,” Nelson said.
Communist policies have left an overwhelming population of abandoned children to state institutions.
Children in overcrowded orphanages often struggle with a stifling, highly-regimented daily routine, Nelson said.
These environments often cause social interaction and attachment problems, autism, and stunted growth.
Without stimulating experience, children develop “brain deprivation” as a result of social neglect.
Nelson’s study found that children suffering from brain deprivation appear physically stunted. The body appears to save essential growth hormones for brain development, he said.
Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Considerations for Multicultural Counselors When Working With Transracial Adoptive Families
Here's the abstract to an article published in the Asia Pacific Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy:
In global terms the number of international adoptions increased over 40% between 1998 and 2004. Research from Canada that surveyed white parents of children adopted transracially on their experiences of pre-and post-adoption services raises a number of issues with implications for multicultural counselling. This study found that many professionals charged with the responsibility of helping to facilitate transracial adoptions need to be better educated in the needs of adoptive children and families. Findings also showed that, because of parents’ lack of preparation in the pre-adoption phase, transracially adopted children may be at risk for medical, social and emotional problems. This paper suggests topics that should be considered in a multicultural counselling setting in order to be responsive to some of the experiences of transracially adoption (sic) children and their parents.I'll try to track down the article and post more about it later.
"The burning desire. . ."
At BlogHer, an adoptee talks about her need to know more about her biological parents:
I found out about my adoption when I was barely five years old. Growing up, it seemed like just another fact, nothing that would come to haunt me -- like knowing my best friend liked cats and had a tendency to break her wrist when she skateboarded. I liked soccer, surfing, and didn't know my birth parents. No big deal.As she describes her desire to keep searching, "The burning desire and curiosity, the need, won't die out."
Once I hit puberty, finding out anything about where I came from was of utmost importance to me. I spent hours in the library, researching adoption laws, e-mailing Congressmen and Senators who voted in favor of adoptee rights, even joining websites that promised the Holy Grail of reconnecting family members. I applied to the Wisconsin department of Children and Family Services to "open" my records.
In the last seven years, I've been turned down six times.
What does the Sandusky case say about gays and lesbians adopting? ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!
Unless it says that more gays and lesbians should be allowed to adopt so that kids in foster care are not vulnerable to pedophiles like Jerry Sandusky. . . .
Not that you would have concluded that from NPR's To the Point, as reported at Gawker:
Not that you would have concluded that from NPR's To the Point, as reported at Gawker:
On Friday, Gawker broke the story of a horrifically ill-conceived installment of Warren Olney's current affairs show on public radio, To The Point. Using the Jerry Sandusky child rape scandal as its jumping-off point, the show somehow drew a dotted line to the topic of gays and lesbians' suitability as foster and adoptive parents. The thinking behind it (and there wasn't much) was that Sandusky was ostensibly a heterosexually married man who had access to foster and adoptive children he could prey on. "With 500,000 children desperate for loving homes," Olney's intro went, "we'll look at efforts to widen the pool of available parents. Should gays and lesbians qualify?" I don't know, Warren. Should they?
* * *
[One of the invited speakers on the show was] Jerry Cox, whose Arkansas Family Council unsuccessfully petitioned the state to ban foster children from entering same-sex-parent homes. (The state Supreme Court unanimously shot down the measure as unconstitutional.) Cox was given a generous platform to preach his particular brand of hate, referring repeatedly to "studies" that proved the "gold standard" for any child was a household headed by "one man and one woman." He also deftly used Olney's lead-in of the Sandusky case — if not to outwardly accuse gay parents of being predisposed to pedophilia, to at least align the two topics snugly: "In both cases," he said, "the children's rights get put in second place." And why not? This was how Olney chose to frame this discussion, after all. But never did Olney challenge Cox's falsehoods or bigotry, or even attempt to establish a delineation between gay parents and pedophilia. In his wildest dreams, Cox couldn't have asked for a more generous platform — not here of all places, in the supposedly liberal bastion of public radio.
* * *
Today, at the end of the To The Point broadcast, Olney issued this, far more contrite announcement. It read, in part:
Apology accepted? Or does the show need to do more? Maybe a whole show to emphasize that there is no connection between pedophilia and homosexuality?! How's that for a starting point?!"With hundreds and thousands of troubled children in need, we thought it was a good time to point out that gay and lesbian couples are often prohibited from both fostering and adopting, even though they can provide loving homes. we failed to point out explicitly that pedophilia and homosexuality are not connected, and that led some listeners to think we were buying into an infamous falsehood. Over the weekend, we received a lot of critical comments from people that by discussing both topics in one show, we had equated the two. We respect our listeners, and we want to respond. There is no connection between pedophilia and homosexuality, and we never intended to say or imply there is. But our failure to make that crucial distinction explicit was a serious oversight. We regret it, and we apologize." [Empasis added, link added]
Monday, November 14, 2011
Different Courts, Different Treatment for LGBT Adoptive Parents
This article, about different courts in Maryland ruling differently in adoption cases involving gay and lesbian parents, is actually fairly typical in all states:
The rows of wooden benches were filled with seven families for adoption day in Baltimore City Circuit Court last month.Most wouldn't be surprised to hear of different states treating gay couples differently for purposes of adoption, but within one state?! Unfortunately, that's fairly common as well. That lack of certainty of legal treatment, even within the same state, is a pretty powerful argument for the proposed federal statute, Every Child Deserves a Family Act, to end discrimination against LGBT parents.
A pair of gay men seeking to adopt a baby. Three lesbian couples, two with twins. Two single moms with two kids between them.
And one heterosexual couple — the only nuclear family with a mother and father — who had filed to adopt a young boy.
Most adoption days in Baltimore look like this. The city is the favored jurisdiction among Maryland's 24 circuit courts for same-sex adoption petitioners because of a legal precedent written 15 years ago and because of local procedures that allow all Maryland residents — regardless of which county they call home — to file adoption paperwork in the city.
Maryland's adoption statute is silent on same-sex parents, leaving the matter to the discretion of each circuit judge. Baltimore, according to adoption lawyers, appears to be the only jurisdiction where judges have agreed to treat homosexual couples the same way they treat straight couples. Other jurisdictions, attorneys say, are a gamble for would-be parents who are gay.
So even as more circuit courts become willing to grant adoptions to same-sex couples — at least seven other counties have done so — lawyers who specialize in representing gay families nearly always tell their clients to file in Baltimore, steering them away from their home counties if judges there are known to turn down adoption applications or if the judicial waters are untested.
Sunday, November 13, 2011
Sandusky's "Angel in Adoption" Award Rescinded
Reported in the Philadelphia Inquirer:
A Washington non-profit group has rescinded a 2002 "Angels in Adoption" award presented to former Penn State defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky, charged with multiple counts of sexual abuse of young boys.
"As an organization that fights to stop child abuse, our thoughts and prayers are with the children harmed and the families affected by his alleged actions," the Congressional Coalition on Adoption Institute said in a statement released Thursday. "This tragedy underscores how important it is to have a foster care system that ensures our most vulnerable children have a safe and stable environment in which to grow."
The group said it was acting to "preserve the inegrity" of the Angels in Adoption Award, which has been presented since 1998 to 1,800 people and organizations who have done exemplary work to help children in need of loving homes.
Former Sen. Rick Santorum of Pennsylvania, a current candidate for the Republican presidential nomination, sponsored the Sanduskys for the award. Santorum has said he is sickened by the allegations and the scandal at his alma matter.
Sandusky was widely admired in the state and nationally for his post-football charitable work, a reminder that alleged child predators can lurk anywhere.
Adoptions More Difficult Since Artyom Sent Away
Touting improved screening and post-adoption scrutiny, which is as it should be, which is very good news:
International adoption has never been easy. It takes time, money, and commitment to bring a child from another land into a new family.
Then last year a woman from Tennessee put her adopted 7-year-old son on a one-way flight back to Russia, and a difficult process got a whole lot harder for a lot more Americans.
Russia banned adoptions to America for the better part of a year. Other nations began requiring much more careful screening and post-adoption follow-up visits for prospective families.
* * *
If any good has come out of the Hansen scandal, it's been to improve the education and training that adoptive families undergo. Parents already go through extensive background checks - criminal and financial - home visits and counseling. Now, the scrutiny is tightening and parents can expect social workers to drop in on them and their new families for as many as five years after the adoption.
"Countries have become more stringent in their criteria" for screening potential adoptive parents, said Julie Bolles of Catholic Charities of Tennessee, which conducts home study visits for a variety of international adoption agencies. "Agencies have become more stringent about educating and preparing adoptive parents."
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Taking Pax Back to Vietnam
From People:
Angelina Jolie keeps quite the busy travel schedule. And though it's often for work, her current trip is in line with her desire to keep her three adopted children familiar with their roots.And according to US Weekly, as reported at a Vietnamese news site, the entire family will visit Pax's orphanage.
Her latest destination: Vietnam, where she was photographed with her son Pax, 7.
"We owe Vietnam a visit, because Pax is due," Jolie, 36, told the Financial Times in July, adding of her six children with Brad Pitt: "They are all learning about each other's cultures as well as being proud of their own. They all have their flags over their beds and their individual pride."
According to the photographer, the actress and Pax went out for lunch together in Ho Chi Minh City, and the rest of the Jolie-Pitt brood is along for the trip as well.
Pitt, 47, and Jolie adopted eldest son Maddox, 10, from Cambodia, Zahara, 6, from Ethiopia. Their daughter Shiloh, 5, was born in Namibia, and twins Vivienne and Knox, 3, in France.
Friday, November 11, 2011
"Do you take care of them?"
The girls and I stopped at a neighborhood convenience store the other day to pick up an after-school snack as we hurried to some after-school activity. We've been in a few times, but not all that often. The clerk always looks puzzled when she looks at us, and often asks something-or-other about our family -- which is pretty much why we don't go in all that often! This time she asked if Zoe and Maya were sisters. I said yes, though I'm pretty sure she was asking if they were biologically related.
Then she asked, "Do you take care of them?" Well, the short answer to that one, too, would be yes. Like mothers do, I take care of my daughters. But I'm not just the baby-sitter, I'm more than a nanny. And that's really what she was asking me, right? Are you the baby-sitter?
I have to admit, there have been times when I've felt like the baby-sitter. I didn't feel like a mother until I had been parenting Zoe for about six months. So I had a bit of a problem with simply answering, "Yes, I take care of them." I wanted to claim them as my family; anything else seemed like a rejection. So I answered, "No, I'm their mother." And out the door we go, a mismatched family of three.
Zoe and Maya were tickled that the lady thought I was their baby-sitter. They've so rarely had a non-family-member baby-sitter that the novelty of it was quite intriguing. After giggling over it for a while, Zoe said, "Well, at least she didn't think you were our grandmother!" Despite my quite youthful looks (!) and my obviously-prematurely-gray hair, we frequently get the "grandmother" question. Sigh.
Then she asked, "Do you take care of them?" Well, the short answer to that one, too, would be yes. Like mothers do, I take care of my daughters. But I'm not just the baby-sitter, I'm more than a nanny. And that's really what she was asking me, right? Are you the baby-sitter?
I have to admit, there have been times when I've felt like the baby-sitter. I didn't feel like a mother until I had been parenting Zoe for about six months. So I had a bit of a problem with simply answering, "Yes, I take care of them." I wanted to claim them as my family; anything else seemed like a rejection. So I answered, "No, I'm their mother." And out the door we go, a mismatched family of three.
Zoe and Maya were tickled that the lady thought I was their baby-sitter. They've so rarely had a non-family-member baby-sitter that the novelty of it was quite intriguing. After giggling over it for a while, Zoe said, "Well, at least she didn't think you were our grandmother!" Despite my quite youthful looks (!) and my obviously-prematurely-gray hair, we frequently get the "grandmother" question. Sigh.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Talking to Kids About Adoption Trafficking
Great and timely article at Adoptive Families mag by Sheena Macrae, whom you may know from EMK Press' Adoption Parenting, covering reasons to tell and tools for telling:
At the nub of such concerns is the reality that the nurturing role of an adoptive parent is tough. You are parenting in the present, and that means making sense of the past. If corruption exists in your child’s birth country or may have played a role in your son's adoption, it is your job to give him a truthful account of his past. Otherwise, the child will certainly find out another way, from his peers, other kids' parents, newspaper headlines that scream "Baby Buying" and "Money-Driven Adoption," Facebook, or YouTube. A child who knows the basics about adoption and trafficking, and his own journey to his family, is empowered by knowing. He is in charge of his story.Lots more good info in the article -- I've just given you a few points here -- so be sure to read the whole thing. You might also be interested in these resources at EMK Press: Telling About Trafficking, also by Macrae, and the Impact of Illegal Adoption on One Family by Julia Rollings.
* * *
If facts are not known, parents can offer "what-ifs," possibilities involving the child's pre-adoption history. These aren’t fictional stories, but reasonable possibilities that may have affected our children, given what we know and can deduce about their circumstances from reading, researching, and the news. Describe the situation in the child's birth country, even if it involves closure, a slowdown, or trafficking. Discussions won't be fruitful until the child is about five years old, but it's good practice to start telling the story earlier, in an age-appropriate way. Here's how to open the dialogue:
1. Tune in together…and then discuss. You might watch kids' news programs on television with a younger child. Read and comment on newspapers with an older child. Current affairs shows can spark discussion. Go lightly. You might talk about how trafficked babies might feel, or what it feels like to work in bad factory conditions or have to work as a street beggar as a child.
* * *
2. After talking or watching a TV program together, always "return" to the security of your home and family. End discussions with hugs, and be prepared for emotions as your child processes what she is learning. Kids around this time might like to see copies of their adoption paperwork or citizenship papers. These things reassure them that their adoption is secure.
* * *
6. Listen to what your child says in response to your discussion-starters; her thoughts matter. Provide extra support if you know there are comments in local newspapers about intercountry adoption and "babies for sale." She may take it to heart, and need extra help.
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
Can Adoption Lead to Child Abuse?
At Huffington Post, Lisa Belkin answers "yes:"
I wish I had the answers. . . . What do you think of Belkin's suggestion? Reactions?
I have not been able to get four-year-old Sean Paddock, or 11-year-old Hanna Williams, or 7-year-old Lydia Schatz out of my mind. As Erik Eckholm reported in the New York Times yesterday, and Anderson Cooper discussed on CNN, most recently last week, the three children all died within the past five years, and they had several chilling factors in common.Belkin also notes that a commenter claiming to know Hana's family wrote:
Each of their deaths were brutal and agonizing: Sean suffocated; Hana, who was found lying naked in the muddy yard, died of hypothermia and malnutrition; Lydia showed signs of a brutal beating. In each case, one or both of their parents has been charged with their murder.
And in each case, those parents are said to have essentially punished their children to death, allegedly because they believed it was God's will. They are said to have been guided by the book To Train Up A Child, by Michael and Debi Pearl, which advocates beating children with rubber tubing, leaving them outside in the cold, and witholding food for days at a time in keeping with Biblical teachings.
* * *
[E]ach of these children joined these families through adoption. Sean was born in the US, as were his five adopted siblings. Hana was from Ethiopia, as was her adopted brother (their parents had six biological children as well), and Lydia was from Liberia (there were two other adopted siblings among the family's nine children).
Is this merely grisly coincidence? Or is there something about the adoption dynamic that makes violent abuse more likely?
One possibility is that adoptive children -- particularly those who spend their earliest years in an orphanage or shuttling from one foster caregiver to the next -- are more likely to suffer reactive attachment disorder, which are essentially the inability not only to bond, but to feel. The effects are not just psychological, but also physical, with evidence these children can have elevated levels of the hormone cortisol, which increases their tolerance for pain. Some speculate that spanking a child with Reactive Attachment Disorder can spiral out of control quickly, because it takes abusive levels of pain before the child actually feels it and responds.
They expected Hana and her little brother to assimilate into their family, and most likely ignored their culture, how they had grown up (customs, beliefs, etc), and most importantly, the trauma that Hana and her brother had gone through in their childhoods. These kids just weren't acting like their biological children. Instead of taking a step back and getting professional help, they decided that they would continue to follow the Pearl method, but continued to up the ante, because these kids were NOT succumbing to being "broken".When we read media reports of adoptive parents who have abused and/or murdered their children, it raises lots of questions. Who commits more abuse, biological or adoptive parents? Is abuse of adopted children because of or in spite of adoption? If adoption is causitive, in what way is it causitive? Are adoptive parents less able to "feel the pain" of a child not biologically related to them? Is that tendency (if it exists) exacerbated if the adoption is transracial? Does RAD and the reaction of the child play a role, as Belkin suggests? Is the stress of adoptive parenting a factor? Is the connection between adoption and religion implicated?
I wish I had the answers. . . . What do you think of Belkin's suggestion? Reactions?
Adoptive Parents Say Doctor Traumatized Them
From the Courthouse News Service, a bizarre story from Florida:
Adoptive parents say a doctor, apparently distraught at his own divorce, refused to hand over their 2-day-old baby unless they "agreed to purchase a plane ticket for the birth mother to visit their daughter and only if plaintiffs agreed to return their daughter to the birth mother when she reached her fifth birthday."The Miami New Times article reporting the lawsuit starts: "It sounds like a tale adoptive parents tell around a campfire to scare each other sleepless." Indeed.
Alleging intentional infliction of emotional distress, Nicole and Bienvenido Olivencia sued Dr. Felipe A. Caballero and Tenet Hialeah Healthsystem dba Hialeah Hospital, in Miami-Dade County Court.
The Olivencias say they traveled from their home in Virginia to Hialeah Hospital in Miami to bring home the baby they were adopting.
On Aug. 9, 2009, they say, they met Caballero, the doctor in charge of signing the 2-day-old baby's discharge papers.
"Felipe A. Caballero M.D. examined the newborn baby girl and determined her to be a well baby and signed the discharge at approximately 11:00 a.m.," according to the complaint.
Then, the Olivencias say, they met with the adoption agency social worker to begin the paperwork and accompany the social worker to the nursery, where custody of the child would be transferred to the social worker.
"When plaintiff and the adoption agency social worker arrived at the nursery Hialeah Hospital, employees informed then that defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. had wrongfully taken plaintiff's daughter outside the nursery and into a separate room without medical facilities for newborns," the complaint states.
The Olivencias say they "found defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. holding their daughter and rocking her with the lights off without their consent, against their will, contrary to Hialeah Hospital policy and procedures and in violation of his duties.
"The adoption agency social worker advised defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. that she required the plaintiff's daughter. Defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. ignored the adoption agency social worker and yelled at plaintiffs, ordering them into the room demanding they answer his questions. Fearing for the well-being and safety of their daughter who defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. was wrongfully holding captive at this point, plaintiffs complied.
"Defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. while continuing to hold plaintiffs' daughter captive and against plaintiffs' will began a verbal assault and personal offensive improper interrogation of plaintiffs, questioning their fitness as parents and insulting them, thereby causing severe emotional distress by his verbal abuse and their growing fear of potential harm to their daughter," according to the complaint.
The Olivencias say Caballero "threatened to call three different lawyers to prevent the adoption if his questions were not answered to his satisfaction.
"Eventually, defendant Felipe A. Caballero M.D. outrageously stated he would approve the adoption to plaintiffs only if plaintiffs agreed to purchase a plane ticket for the birth mother to visit their daughter and only if plaintiffs agreed to return their daughter to the birth mother when she reached her fifth birthday."
The Olivencias say they "were intimidated and coerced into" agreeing to Caballero's demands because they were "(d)esperate to have their daughter, distraught concerning her safety and fearing the adoption process was jeopardized ...".
Tuesday, November 8, 2011
Beware Orphanage Scams
At E.J. Graff's Prospect blog, a warning to those who want to donate to orphanage and to biological families who think they are dealing with reputable orphanages:
Beware of overseas orphanages seeking donations. If you're not careful, you may become the victim of an orphanage scam—in which a savvy entrepreneur in a poor country hustles up some children so that he or she can ask developed-world humanitarians for money for the children's support. In some of the notorious cases, the orphanage director pockets the money while the children are left to starve or sold for sex. Few people know that they may be underwriting kidnapping or other modes of defrauding local families out of their children. In other cases, the traffickers put the children—who are neither abandoned nor orphaned—up for international adoption, which can bring in astonishing fees.
One version of the orphanage scam has just been uncovered in India by the Esther Benjamins Memorial Foundation. Several years ago, a now-infamous child-trafficker traveled through Nepal's Humla province, asking families to pay him to take their children to boarding schools in Kathmandu. Instead, according to information I received from Joseph Aguettant of the child welfare NGO Terre des Hommes, many of the boys were sold into international adoption, while many girls were sold into the sex trade in India. (You can see Joseph Aguettant's documentary of the Nepal adoption issues, "Paper Orphans," on You Tube here: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, and Part 4).
Citizenship for ALL U.S. Intercountry Adoptees
There's a petition at Change.org asking Congress to fill the gap left in the Child Citizenship Act of 2000 that has led to the deportation of international adoptees whose parents have failed to take the required steps for them to receive citizenship:
For the sake of Joao Herbert, Matthew Sherer, John Gaul, Tara Ammons Cohen, Tatiana Mitrohina, Jennifer Haynes, Seo, and many, many more, including those unnamed and unknown -- please sign the petition and share it with your friends.
"The Child Citizenship Act of 2000 allows certain foreign-born, biological and adopted children of American citizens to acquire American citizenship automatically. These children did not acquire American citizenship at birth, but they are granted citizenship when they enter the United States as lawful permanent residents (LPRs)." U.S. Department of StateMy children benefitted from the automatic citizenship provisions of the Child Citizenship Act. Shouldn't all international adoptees have the same benefit? Why would we visit the sins of the parents (failure to acquire citizenship for their children) on those unwitting children?
One of the requirements of the Child Citizenship Act of 2000 (CCA 2000) was that the adoptee be under the age of 18 on its effective date, February 27, 2001. International adoptees 18 and older were not granted citizenship under its provisions. Some, but not all, obtained citizenship through their own efforts or those of their adoptive parents. Of those who did not, many were unaware that they lacked this legal protection. Being without citizenship while believing they possessed it placed these intercountry adoptees at risk of violating U.S Federal law through no fault of their own by representing themselves as citizens upon return to the United States at any port of entry (including Canada and Mexico), applying for public benefits (including Federal education aid), or voting in Federal or other elections.
Further, strict immigration policies under the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 increased the risk of deportation. This law does not provide for “discretionary relief,” which would allow the unique circumstances that led to an adoptee's lack of citizenship to be taken into consideration in determining outcomes. Adoptees have faced deportation and have been deported to countries in Asia, Latin America and Europe - countries unknown to them in every way: language, culture, family or friends. Additionally, adoptees without citizenship who travel to their countries of birth may be subject to laws there that prevent their return to the United States.
For the sake of Joao Herbert, Matthew Sherer, John Gaul, Tara Ammons Cohen, Tatiana Mitrohina, Jennifer Haynes, Seo, and many, many more, including those unnamed and unknown -- please sign the petition and share it with your friends.
Turning a Lens on China Adoption
A profile of Dr. Changfu Chang from the Philadephia Inquirer:
Millersville University professor Changfu Chang figured his first documentary on Chinese adoption would be his last.Given his unique place in China adoption, it isn't surprising that I've posted quite a bit about Dr. Chang before.
After all, how much could he say on the topic?
He thought the same about his second film. And his third, fourth, and fifth.
Now, with eight documentaries in print and a ninth in production, Chang has accepted that the careful examination of this one complicated corner of humanity is in fact his life's work and calling. The story of the adopted children, mostly girls, about 80,000 strong, has moved in directions no one could have anticipated since he produced Love Without Boundaries in 2003.
"I feel like there's more urgency," Chang said in an interview, adding: "You feel like you're part of this global community."
It's not what he expected. Not while working as a reporter for Fujian Television in China, nor while studying mass communication as a doctoral student at Purdue University.
* * *
More recently the narrative around the one-child policy has been upset by news that officials in Hunan seized babies and sold them into a lucrative black market. In August, the New York Times reported that at least 16 children were taken between 1999 and 2006. Officials threatened big fines against couples who had "illegal" births, then took children when parents could not pay.
Chang said he believed China's system was basically clean. At the same time, his films show that girls enter orphanages in many different ways, with complicated backstories, and that official accounts may not bear scrutiny.
Monday, November 7, 2011
Cabbage Patch Dolls to Raise Money for Adoption Awareness?
I kid you not, a Steven Tyler Cabbage Patch doll:
So what do you think? Are Cabbage Patch dolls good spokesmodels for adoption awareness? After all, they come from under a cabbage leaf, no pesky birth parents in sight, no prior history at all, just a birth certificate signed by the famous baby him/herself. . . .
Rocker Steven Tyler and actresses Katherine Heigl and Kristin Chenoweth have been immortalised as one-of-a-kind Cabbage Patch Kids dolls for a charity auction.Oh, and don't forget Al Roker. He's included, too.
Former child star Raven-Symone has also been 'Patched' as part of a special celebrity range to raise funds for U.S. adoption organisation the Children's Action Network (Can).
The dolls are being sold via auction website ebay.com and each one comes complete with its own autographed birth certificate.
So what do you think? Are Cabbage Patch dolls good spokesmodels for adoption awareness? After all, they come from under a cabbage leaf, no pesky birth parents in sight, no prior history at all, just a birth certificate signed by the famous baby him/herself. . . .
November is National Adoption Awareness Month
Last year's post on this subject I titled In Case You've Been Living in a Cave, Snowed In Without Newspapers, and Your Cable Was Knocked Out and Your Antenna Knocked Down, and You Just Had Your Internet Service Restored But You Can't Remember Your Facebook Password, Twitter is Over Capacity, Though You Can Finally Catch Up on Your Blog Reading, Here's the BIG News You Missed: November is Adoption Awareness Month! Can you tell I get a little tired of all the hoopla about adoption in November? Well, this is what I said last year, in case you missed it, which hopefully is still relevant a year later:
November is National Adoption Month, and we're asked everywhere to "celebrate" adoption. I admit, I have a hard time with that. I acknowledge that, as an adoptive parent, I'm the only one in the adoption triad who didn't come to adoption through tragedy. How can I "celebrate" the tragedy that made my children available for adoption? But I can certainly accept a national adoption AWARENESS month, which happens to be the official name. There are LOTS of things people need to be aware of when it comes to adoption.
I thought I'd go through Adoptive Families Magazine's 30 Ways to Celebrate National Adoption Month article, and suggest some ways that their ideas could be tweaked a bit to increase awareness, both inside your family and out:
2. Ask your library to display adoption books to commemorate National Adoption Awareness Month.
Here are some books to suggest -- books from the important perspective of adopted persons, and books that reveal a history of adoption that is often ignored:
The Language of Blood
by Jane Jeong Trenka
Fugitive Visions
by Jane Jeong Trenka
Outsiders Within: Writing on Transracial Adoption
Orphan Train
: Placing Out in America
Kinship by Design:
A History of Adoption in the Modern United States
The Girls Who Went Away
by Ann Fessler
5. Find out where your representatives at the state and national level stand on adoption issues. Write to them regarding your concerns.
You can click here to find out your state's position on adoptee access to original birth certificates. Chances are, your state does not allow such access since only 6 states do. The American Adoption Congress provides lots of online materials to help you inform legislators on this issue.
7. Create a scrapbook with your child. Talk about significant events as you record them together.
Make sure you include significant events -- such as BIRTH! -- that occurred before you and your child met. Here's a link about adoption lifebooks to get your started.
9. Find an adult adoptee or a person of color—a coach, a teacher, or a babysitter—who can serve as a mentor for your child. Arrange for them to get together monthly.
If your area is not very diverse, you need to act intentionally to bring adults who share your child's race into their lives. Pediatrician, dentist, eye doctor -- given a choice, choose the one who shares your child's race. Getting to know adult adopted persons can be a great help in letting kids know someone older and wiser who can listen to their problems.
11. Spend some time celebrating your child’s heritage.
The internet is a wonderful place to find recipes, traditions, folklore, about your child's birth country.
13. Give an adoption talk at school.
Keep it real, keep it age-appropriate, and talk as much as you can about how families can be different, and that's OK.
14. Pass along an adoption-related article to another adoptive parent or friend.
Here are a few I'd suggest:
The Lie We Love by E.J. Graff
The Baby Business: Policy Proposals for Fairer Practice by E.J. Graff
Anatomy of an Adoption Crisis by E.J. Graff
I'd also suggest that you share blog links -- especially adult adoptee and birth mother blogs -- with your adoptive parent friends. It's so important for all adoptive parents to read from all perspectives, especially from those that might be different from their own. Check out the links in the blog roll to your right. Send your favorites via email, Facebook and/or Twitter to your friends.
20. NATIONAL ADOPTION DAY! Courts across the country will finalize thousands of adoptions today.
These are adoptions from foster care. If you are an attorney, consider volunteering. Remember, courts are open to the public. Feel free to visit your courthouse and watch the finalizations. This can be a great experience for kids, especially if they were too young to remember their own, or if they are experiencing anxiety about how permanent their adoption is. You can show them how the judge makes a family a family forever. Click here to check for events in your area.
21. Develop a family ritual to show thanks for your family and the special way you’ve found one another AND 27. Together, light a candle in honor of your child’s birthparents. Turn off the lights and hold hands as you watch the flame.
I love family rituals, and combining 21 and 27 acknowledges that your child's birth family is part of your family. For some suggestions of family rituals, check out Creating Ceremonies: Innovative Ways to Meet Adoption Challenges.
I also think rituals are extremely important when a child's birth parents are unknown. Rituals can give them a concrete presence in a child's life. My kids, for example, write notes to birth moms on Mother's Day, and burn the notes so that the smoke can carry good wishes to them in China.
28. Make holiday crafts that incorporate designs from your child’s heritage.
Again, the internet is your friend here!
30. Make a donation in your child’s or birthmother’s name to an adoption-related charity or organization.
Tw of my favorites are family preservation funds; after all, the only way to solve the orphan crisis is to prevent kids from being orphaned in the first place. So check out:
The Unity Fund from Love Without Boundaries
The Family Preservation Initiative from Ethica
So get out there and do your part for adoption awareness -- awareness of ALL the issues in adoption, the good and bad, the happy and sad. That's the awareness the public needs, that's the awareness you need to help your child.
November is National Adoption Month, and we're asked everywhere to "celebrate" adoption. I admit, I have a hard time with that. I acknowledge that, as an adoptive parent, I'm the only one in the adoption triad who didn't come to adoption through tragedy. How can I "celebrate" the tragedy that made my children available for adoption? But I can certainly accept a national adoption AWARENESS month, which happens to be the official name. There are LOTS of things people need to be aware of when it comes to adoption.
I thought I'd go through Adoptive Families Magazine's 30 Ways to Celebrate National Adoption Month article, and suggest some ways that their ideas could be tweaked a bit to increase awareness, both inside your family and out:
2. Ask your library to display adoption books to commemorate National Adoption Awareness Month.
Here are some books to suggest -- books from the important perspective of adopted persons, and books that reveal a history of adoption that is often ignored:
The Language of Blood
Fugitive Visions
Outsiders Within: Writing on Transracial Adoption
Orphan Train
Kinship by Design:
The Girls Who Went Away
5. Find out where your representatives at the state and national level stand on adoption issues. Write to them regarding your concerns.
You can click here to find out your state's position on adoptee access to original birth certificates. Chances are, your state does not allow such access since only 6 states do. The American Adoption Congress provides lots of online materials to help you inform legislators on this issue.
7. Create a scrapbook with your child. Talk about significant events as you record them together.
Make sure you include significant events -- such as BIRTH! -- that occurred before you and your child met. Here's a link about adoption lifebooks to get your started.
9. Find an adult adoptee or a person of color—a coach, a teacher, or a babysitter—who can serve as a mentor for your child. Arrange for them to get together monthly.
If your area is not very diverse, you need to act intentionally to bring adults who share your child's race into their lives. Pediatrician, dentist, eye doctor -- given a choice, choose the one who shares your child's race. Getting to know adult adopted persons can be a great help in letting kids know someone older and wiser who can listen to their problems.
11. Spend some time celebrating your child’s heritage.
The internet is a wonderful place to find recipes, traditions, folklore, about your child's birth country.
13. Give an adoption talk at school.
Keep it real, keep it age-appropriate, and talk as much as you can about how families can be different, and that's OK.
14. Pass along an adoption-related article to another adoptive parent or friend.
Here are a few I'd suggest:
The Lie We Love by E.J. Graff
The Baby Business: Policy Proposals for Fairer Practice by E.J. Graff
Anatomy of an Adoption Crisis by E.J. Graff
I'd also suggest that you share blog links -- especially adult adoptee and birth mother blogs -- with your adoptive parent friends. It's so important for all adoptive parents to read from all perspectives, especially from those that might be different from their own. Check out the links in the blog roll to your right. Send your favorites via email, Facebook and/or Twitter to your friends.
20. NATIONAL ADOPTION DAY! Courts across the country will finalize thousands of adoptions today.
These are adoptions from foster care. If you are an attorney, consider volunteering. Remember, courts are open to the public. Feel free to visit your courthouse and watch the finalizations. This can be a great experience for kids, especially if they were too young to remember their own, or if they are experiencing anxiety about how permanent their adoption is. You can show them how the judge makes a family a family forever. Click here to check for events in your area.
21. Develop a family ritual to show thanks for your family and the special way you’ve found one another AND 27. Together, light a candle in honor of your child’s birthparents. Turn off the lights and hold hands as you watch the flame.
I love family rituals, and combining 21 and 27 acknowledges that your child's birth family is part of your family. For some suggestions of family rituals, check out Creating Ceremonies: Innovative Ways to Meet Adoption Challenges.
I also think rituals are extremely important when a child's birth parents are unknown. Rituals can give them a concrete presence in a child's life. My kids, for example, write notes to birth moms on Mother's Day, and burn the notes so that the smoke can carry good wishes to them in China.
28. Make holiday crafts that incorporate designs from your child’s heritage.
Again, the internet is your friend here!
30. Make a donation in your child’s or birthmother’s name to an adoption-related charity or organization.
Tw of my favorites are family preservation funds; after all, the only way to solve the orphan crisis is to prevent kids from being orphaned in the first place. So check out:
The Unity Fund from Love Without Boundaries
The Family Preservation Initiative from Ethica
So get out there and do your part for adoption awareness -- awareness of ALL the issues in adoption, the good and bad, the happy and sad. That's the awareness the public needs, that's the awareness you need to help your child.
Sunday, November 6, 2011
Puss in Boots, Orphan
Zoe wanted to see Puss in Boots for her birthday, so off we go. I knew there would be orphan themes, given the inclusion of the movie in Jeff Alexander's Time piece, Children's Movies Have Too Many Orphans.
*WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD*
The back-story for Puss is that a desert wind blew his basket (no explanation of how he got in the basket) right to the steps of an orphanage. He is taken in by the head of the orphanage, whom he later calls Mama. Mama is alternately proud of Puss and too ready to condemn him without listening, but she isn't an evil caricature of an orphanage head, nor is the orphanage a dark and depressing place.
At the orphanage, Puss meets Humpty Dumpty and they become blood/yolk brothers. They have an idyllic childhood of hijinks until Humpty goes too far and drags Puss into his life of crime. Humpty is caught and goes to jail, and Puss now has a price on his head. In current time, Humpty tricks Puss into stealing the goose that lays golden eggs so that he can turn Puss into the police as revenge for Puss deserting him and letting him go to jail.
In the end, Humpty and Puss reconcile and Humpty sacrifices himself for the greater good.
As one would expect, there are themes of abandonment and the meaning of family, though they are not very thoroughly developed. There is much dialogue about Puss and Humpty as brothers, and how brothers should treat each other. I don't think the word "adoption" was ever mentioned in the movie, and even in scenes after Puss calls the orphanage head Mama, both Puss and Humpty refer to themselves as orphans.
Also not developed but suggestive was Kitty Soft-Paw's back-story. She recounts that she was taken in by a couple who fed her milk and loved her -- and then de-clawed her. She expresses pain and grief over losing her claws. She doesn't know why they de-clawed her, but she says maybe she clawed the curtains or played too rough with the hamster.
Hmmm, I can certainly read some adoptee themes here -- that often adoptive families expect adoptees to change, rather than the family change to accommodate the adoptee, and the adoptee's self-blame when that change is presented as necessary. But, again, these themes were not really developed in any way.
All in all, it was pretty innocuous on the adoption front. I think it helped that Puss is an animal (though certainly anthropomorphized) in a world of humans; his adoptive mother is human, so it comes across more as "animal adoption" rather than "transracial (trans-species?) adoption" like in Kung Fu Panda 2, where panda Po is adopted by Papa goose. The only problem my kids had with the film was that Humpty gets scrambled at the end.
So there you have it. Do with it what you will!
*WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD*
The back-story for Puss is that a desert wind blew his basket (no explanation of how he got in the basket) right to the steps of an orphanage. He is taken in by the head of the orphanage, whom he later calls Mama. Mama is alternately proud of Puss and too ready to condemn him without listening, but she isn't an evil caricature of an orphanage head, nor is the orphanage a dark and depressing place.
At the orphanage, Puss meets Humpty Dumpty and they become blood/yolk brothers. They have an idyllic childhood of hijinks until Humpty goes too far and drags Puss into his life of crime. Humpty is caught and goes to jail, and Puss now has a price on his head. In current time, Humpty tricks Puss into stealing the goose that lays golden eggs so that he can turn Puss into the police as revenge for Puss deserting him and letting him go to jail.
In the end, Humpty and Puss reconcile and Humpty sacrifices himself for the greater good.
As one would expect, there are themes of abandonment and the meaning of family, though they are not very thoroughly developed. There is much dialogue about Puss and Humpty as brothers, and how brothers should treat each other. I don't think the word "adoption" was ever mentioned in the movie, and even in scenes after Puss calls the orphanage head Mama, both Puss and Humpty refer to themselves as orphans.
Also not developed but suggestive was Kitty Soft-Paw's back-story. She recounts that she was taken in by a couple who fed her milk and loved her -- and then de-clawed her. She expresses pain and grief over losing her claws. She doesn't know why they de-clawed her, but she says maybe she clawed the curtains or played too rough with the hamster.
Hmmm, I can certainly read some adoptee themes here -- that often adoptive families expect adoptees to change, rather than the family change to accommodate the adoptee, and the adoptee's self-blame when that change is presented as necessary. But, again, these themes were not really developed in any way.
All in all, it was pretty innocuous on the adoption front. I think it helped that Puss is an animal (though certainly anthropomorphized) in a world of humans; his adoptive mother is human, so it comes across more as "animal adoption" rather than "transracial (trans-species?) adoption" like in Kung Fu Panda 2, where panda Po is adopted by Papa goose. The only problem my kids had with the film was that Humpty gets scrambled at the end.
So there you have it. Do with it what you will!
Saturday, November 5, 2011
Almost 11!
Tomorrow is Zoe's birthday! Tonight we had a small celebration with friends and family after Chinese School. It was Zoe's choice of restaurant, and she picked Chinese (what a surprise!). I was just happy to have one last kid-priced meal -- tomorrow we can no long pay the 10-and-under buffet price!
Zoe's friends, all China adoptees, and the wait staff at the restaurant, all Chinese, sang her Happy Birthday first in Chinese and then in English. The restaurant then played happy birthday in Chinese over the loudspeaker, and brought her a pretty plate of dessert.
Zoe's friends, all China adoptees, and the wait staff at the restaurant, all Chinese, sang her Happy Birthday first in Chinese and then in English. The restaurant then played happy birthday in Chinese over the loudspeaker, and brought her a pretty plate of dessert.
I don't know how we're going to top this tomorrow, on her actual birthday!
Friday, November 4, 2011
Joan Didion: Adoptive Parent
This review of Blue Nights, Joan Didion's memoir of her daughter's death, excerpts some parts of the book about the adoption of Quintana Roo:
I heard an interview with Didion this week where she talked about her guilt that her daughter died, that she felt she had an added responsibility because of the adoption, that she was given the child to care for, and she felt she failed in that responsibility. Do you have that feeling of added responsibility? I remember a friend whose daughter adopted from China had broken her nose shortly after she came home. When the mom called me, she said in despair, "I've had her for less than 6 months, and I already broke her!"
Has anyone read the book yet? If so, let us know what you think.
What would have been Quintana's seventh wedding anniversary prompts a stream of reminiscences. Didion recounts that she was in the shower when Dunne told her that a doctor had just called to say there was "a beautiful baby girl" up for adoption. She burst into tears.Is Didion right, do "all adoptive parents fear that they do not deserve the child they were given?" Is that your fear?
* * *
Quintana, as an adopted child, worried about abandonment: what would have happened if Dunne and Didion had not been home when that all-important phone call came, she asks. What would have happened to her if they had had an accident on their way to picking her up from the hospital?
Didion, a worrywart even in happy times, obsessed about things happening to her daughter. "All adoptive parents fear that they do not deserve the child they were given, that the child will be taken from them. Quintana. Quintana is one of the areas about which I have difficulty being direct," Didion writes.
I heard an interview with Didion this week where she talked about her guilt that her daughter died, that she felt she had an added responsibility because of the adoption, that she was given the child to care for, and she felt she failed in that responsibility. Do you have that feeling of added responsibility? I remember a friend whose daughter adopted from China had broken her nose shortly after she came home. When the mom called me, she said in despair, "I've had her for less than 6 months, and I already broke her!"
Has anyone read the book yet? If so, let us know what you think.
Children's Movies Have Too Many Orphans
So says Jeff Alexander at Time Magazine, with the tag line, "Parental separation makes for a great plot point, but try telling that to a parent of an adopted child."
Consider for a moment some of our children’s greatest fictional heroes. Luke Skywalker grows up thinking his father is dead. Harry Potter: orphaned as an infant. Ditto Superman. One looks further into the literary pantheon for the pint-sized — Cinderella, Spiderman, Tarzan, Sleeping Beauty, Lemony Snicket’s Baudelaire children, Batman, C.S. Lewis’s Pevensie kids — and it’s hard not to spot a common familial theme: where the hell are all these kids’ folks?Reactions?
Obviously it’s Mythmaking 101 to begin a hero’s journey with some initiating trauma. But does that trauma have to occur so frequently before the hero’s earliest memory? Maybe it does.
* * *
I hasten to add that Max is a happy, well-adjusted child. . . .
But some adopted children under less happy circumstances, like Harry Potter with his hateful relatives at 4 Privet Drive, struggle with abandonment issues and other psychological hurdles. Even kids who land with adoptive parents as loving and supportive as Jonathan and Martha Kent may wonder why they were “given up.” (Actually, the correct term is placed. Bridle against PC language if you will, but watch what you say in front of my kid). And as such, should parental separation be such commonplace story fodder for entertainment aimed at kids?
* * *
For plenty of kids, stories about young people with dead, absent or galactically evil parents are a novelty, a look into a different life. For other kids, they can be a raw nerve. Most raw nerves are treated with some sensitivity, but not this one.
Thursday, November 3, 2011
Why We Tell the Truth
At Salon's advice column, Since You Asked, an adoptive mother essentially asks for permission NOT to tell her child she's adopted:
So I guess we need to go back to the basics of WHY we talk adoption with our kids.
1. We tell our children from the very beginning that they are adopted because it is in their best interests that we do so; whether it is best for us, the adoptive parents, doesn't matter. It is good for us, too, but the only thing that really counts here is our children.
2. It is every human's right to know their own story. Our children's stories begin before we enter the picture, even with newborn adoption. They have a right to know, we have a duty to tell.
3. Openness and honesty are FUNDAMENTAL to healthy relationships, and that includes the relationship between parent and child. How would you feel if someone you loved kept a big secret from you "for your own good?" Once trust is destroyed, it will be nearly impossible to get back.
4. Keeping secrets is hard. All the psychic energy put into keeping adoption a secret takes a toll on the adoptive parent and the parent-child relationship. If you have to be so careful NOT to reveal the secret, and guard against anyone else telling the secret, where's the room for a genuine relationship?
5. It is almost impossible to keep a secret that anyone else knows. I remember walking in on an adult discussion as a child and learning a BIG family secret. Children eventually find things out, and one social worker has written that adoptive children, who often feel the presence of secrets, are more likely to snoop in order to discover those secrets. How do you think a child would react to learning the truth from someone else, rather than from her parents? See breaking trust, above!
6. Don't you want your child to hear it from you instead of someone else? Who do you think would do a better job of telling your child she's adopted -- you, or her cousin taunting her about it? Face the fact that it is inevitable that your child will find out. Let it be from you, who can be gentle and supportive, not from near-strangers.
7. We keep bad things secret. So if you are keeping adoption secret, once your child finds out, she will learn from your previous silence that adoption is bad, shameful, something not to be discussed.
8. Biology matters. It isn't safe for an adopted person to assume they share the same genetic heritage as their adoptive family. Filling out medical history forms, needing a blood transfusion, any number of reasons make it important for adoption information to be shared. This is the case EVEN IF WE CAN'T SHARE INFO ABOUT BIRTH PARENTS BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW IT!
Can you add to the list of WHY we must disclose early and often in the comments?
Oh, and you might want to check out the reaction of first mothers to the Salon piece at Birth Mother, First Mother Forum. And check out this piece in the Australian Family Relationships Quarterly about late-discovery adoptees and their issues.
I've always thought that the WHY of telling is a no-brainer. Harder is the HOW of telling, which is why I tend to blog more about that. Here are some previous posts that I hope are helpful on the HOW of telling:
Ten Commandments of Telling
Talking Adoption Tips
Planting Seeds
Have You REALLY Told Her She's Adopted?
"Let's Play Adoption"
Telling About Abandonment
Crafting Your Adoption Story
Should You Talk? Should You Wait For Questions?
The only problem, Cary, is that despite being educated and well informed, I can not imagine telling my daughter that she is adopted.Even worse, after a few stabs at suggesting it might be a good idea to tell her the truth, the columnist gives her the permission she seeks:
* * *
From the start I started getting irrationally offended when friends referred to it. I cut off someone because she said “oh, she has really taken to you.” Like, why should she not, she is my daughter. I regret that this was shared with the whole family and I had a bit of a showdown where I made it clear that this is not something we discuss or even refer to whenever we meet or ever. Everything I read tells me that this information should be shared early. However, I also read that adopted children grapple with the issue, agonize over it. I mean, why should my lovely daughter have to deal with something her peers do not? Also, her birth mother cannot be traced. The information will really not help her get her genetic or medical information. If after a childhood of happy memories she does come to know, would it really shock her so much? Surely she would be strong enough to deal with it then.
* * *
I am going crazy, Cary, I can’t think straight. Isn’t love enough? . . . I just want to be her mother, not her adoptive mother.
What would you learn if you learned you were adopted?Wow. I don't even know where to start. How about with birth-mother-as-car? And if it's international adoption, I suppose she's an exotic foreign car?! Now, I'm familiar with the whole birth-mother-as-medical-equipment thing, as merely a pass-through body, as the wrong tummy. But this is my first exposure to birth-mother-as-car. God.
You would learn that what you thought was true wasn’t true. It would be more a kind of unlearning than learning. It would be an acquisition of not-knowledge.
Maybe it would be like learning that most of the universe is dark matter and dark energy. You would have to start over. That might not be a bad thing. You might acquire a new, more flexible notion of selfhood.
For one thing, you would have to conclude that you are not your genetic origin, right? Ideally, you would learn that you are a unique being, much loved, who came to be in a particular family here through unique circumstances.
* * *
Let’s put it this way: What does it matter whose car we came in? We’re at the party now.
So I guess we need to go back to the basics of WHY we talk adoption with our kids.
1. We tell our children from the very beginning that they are adopted because it is in their best interests that we do so; whether it is best for us, the adoptive parents, doesn't matter. It is good for us, too, but the only thing that really counts here is our children.
2. It is every human's right to know their own story. Our children's stories begin before we enter the picture, even with newborn adoption. They have a right to know, we have a duty to tell.
3. Openness and honesty are FUNDAMENTAL to healthy relationships, and that includes the relationship between parent and child. How would you feel if someone you loved kept a big secret from you "for your own good?" Once trust is destroyed, it will be nearly impossible to get back.
4. Keeping secrets is hard. All the psychic energy put into keeping adoption a secret takes a toll on the adoptive parent and the parent-child relationship. If you have to be so careful NOT to reveal the secret, and guard against anyone else telling the secret, where's the room for a genuine relationship?
5. It is almost impossible to keep a secret that anyone else knows. I remember walking in on an adult discussion as a child and learning a BIG family secret. Children eventually find things out, and one social worker has written that adoptive children, who often feel the presence of secrets, are more likely to snoop in order to discover those secrets. How do you think a child would react to learning the truth from someone else, rather than from her parents? See breaking trust, above!
6. Don't you want your child to hear it from you instead of someone else? Who do you think would do a better job of telling your child she's adopted -- you, or her cousin taunting her about it? Face the fact that it is inevitable that your child will find out. Let it be from you, who can be gentle and supportive, not from near-strangers.
7. We keep bad things secret. So if you are keeping adoption secret, once your child finds out, she will learn from your previous silence that adoption is bad, shameful, something not to be discussed.
8. Biology matters. It isn't safe for an adopted person to assume they share the same genetic heritage as their adoptive family. Filling out medical history forms, needing a blood transfusion, any number of reasons make it important for adoption information to be shared. This is the case EVEN IF WE CAN'T SHARE INFO ABOUT BIRTH PARENTS BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW IT!
Can you add to the list of WHY we must disclose early and often in the comments?
Oh, and you might want to check out the reaction of first mothers to the Salon piece at Birth Mother, First Mother Forum. And check out this piece in the Australian Family Relationships Quarterly about late-discovery adoptees and their issues.
I've always thought that the WHY of telling is a no-brainer. Harder is the HOW of telling, which is why I tend to blog more about that. Here are some previous posts that I hope are helpful on the HOW of telling:
Ten Commandments of Telling
Talking Adoption Tips
Planting Seeds
Have You REALLY Told Her She's Adopted?
"Let's Play Adoption"
Telling About Abandonment
Crafting Your Adoption Story
Should You Talk? Should You Wait For Questions?
Wednesday, November 2, 2011
Wary of International Adoption
From Christianity Today's Her.meneutics blog, the blogger shares her experience of signing on with an adoption agency just before it was revealed they were engaging in child trafficking:
It wasn’t too long before the Department of State warned that Ethiopia’s Charities and Services Agency had revoked BFAS’s license to operate in Ethiopia due to alleged “license misuse.” That’s the nice way of putting it. The less-sanitized words used in the letter from the Charities and Services agency were “child trafficking”—including falsifying documents to make children look like they were abandoned who, in fact, still had biological parents. (Under Ethiopian law, it’s illegal for a child with living parents to be adopted.) We were stunned and grateful that we hadn’t signed with the organization, as the State Department was urging parents with dossiers in progress to “seek legal aid.”
News like this has made many Westerners wary of international adoption. A few months ago, a Nation article unflatteringly described the resurgence of interest in adoptions among evangelicals as a “crusade,” inspired in large part by Russell Moore’s popular book Adopted for Life. In the article, Kathryn Joyce positions Christian adoption enthusiasts as blustering, blundering consumers who could care less about the ethical dilemmas surrounding international adoption. Yes, I’m slightly uncomfortable when Moore says that adopted kids “don’t know the flags of their home countries” but “know ‘Jesus Loves Me, ” but I’m willing to take that statement along with careful and ethically reasoned perspectives Moore and other evangelicals offer. Jedd Medefind’s response in Christianity Today was, I thought, a gracious one: Learn from the criticism. The ethical dilemmas surrounding adoption—and inter-country adoption especially—can’t be avoided by loving Jesus, loving kids, and hoping for the best. But, as Medefind, writes:
“we dare not turn from sacrifice and hard decisions and return to comfortable homes and lives simply because the cost and complexity are too great.”
Tuesday, November 1, 2011
"Child of my own"
Zoe had her first experience of that phrase, "child of my own," that people use to mean biological children and to distinguish biological children from adopted children. No, she didn't hear it from me; she is my own child! It happened at school, when the class was discussing the vocabulary word "labor." Though the teacher tried to avoid any connection to pregnancy, not wanting to talk about THAT in the classroom, that's exactly where the students went!
A boy in Zoe's class said he felt sorry for women, since they had to go through labor. Zoe informed him smartly that women didn't HAVE to go through labor, they could always adopt! The little boy responded that he wanted a "child of my own." Zoe understood that right away to mean that he didn't want to adopt, he wanted to have a biological child. She asked him why he didn't want to adopt, and he just shrugged.
That usage, "child of my own," to mean biological child is something that adoptive parents rail against. We're driven crazy by statements/questions like this:
Would you rather adopt or have a child of your own?
[P]ersonally, if I do not get married nor have a child of my own around the age of 25, I am adopting.
And whether we adopt or use a surrogate, or have our own natural child. . . .
Now that you’ve adopted you'll probably get pregnant and have a child of your own.
It even makes this list of top 10 things not to say to adoptive parents, in the number 1 spot even, with the appropriate response:
I was really surprised that the little boy, aged 10 or 11, already knew that phrase, and had already internalized the heirarchy of biological parentage over adoption.
As she usually does, Zoe did a good job standing up for herself and adoption. It's just too bad she has to.
A boy in Zoe's class said he felt sorry for women, since they had to go through labor. Zoe informed him smartly that women didn't HAVE to go through labor, they could always adopt! The little boy responded that he wanted a "child of my own." Zoe understood that right away to mean that he didn't want to adopt, he wanted to have a biological child. She asked him why he didn't want to adopt, and he just shrugged.
That usage, "child of my own," to mean biological child is something that adoptive parents rail against. We're driven crazy by statements/questions like this:
Would you rather adopt or have a child of your own?
[P]ersonally, if I do not get married nor have a child of my own around the age of 25, I am adopting.
And whether we adopt or use a surrogate, or have our own natural child. . . .
Now that you’ve adopted you'll probably get pregnant and have a child of your own.
It even makes this list of top 10 things not to say to adoptive parents, in the number 1 spot even, with the appropriate response:
Is it difficult to love a child who isn’t your own?Of course, one could object to either adopted or biological children being termed "a child of my own," with its connotation of ownership. But if you're going to call one a "child of my own," then by golly, call both that! Any other usage brands adopted children as second-class citizens, Plan B, the last resort.
My children are my own — both of them. Yes, I know what you mean. And I repeat: both of my children are "my own."
I was really surprised that the little boy, aged 10 or 11, already knew that phrase, and had already internalized the heirarchy of biological parentage over adoption.
As she usually does, Zoe did a good job standing up for herself and adoption. It's just too bad she has to.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





