Sunday, November 14, 2010

A Chinese Face

The other day, Maya and Zoe were chatting in the back seat while I was driving them to ballet.  Suddenly, I heard Maya say, "I don't like having a Chinese face."

I wasn't overly surprised;  Maya doesn't like being different and sees being Chinese as different.  When I asked why, she confirmed what I thought.  She felt "left out" at school because only she and one other girl in her class have "Chinese faces."

Zoe jumped in immediately to tell Maya how wonderful it is to be Chinese -- my girls are very different on this point!  Zoe loves being Chinese, loves being able to share with others all things Chinese (Zoe's adoption issues are different from Maya's, all about loss and grief and missing her birth family, while Maya professes to have no interest in her birth family, but doesn't like how transracial adoption makes her different). 

My contribution, then, had to be about Maya's feelings since Zoe was so insistent on the it's-wonderful-to-be-Chinese front. We talked about how normal it was to feel the way she does, and that it's OK to feel that way even when Zoe doesn't! I told her about other transracial adoptees who feel the way she does, and she was really fascinated to hear that -- mostly because it was different from how Zoe feels.

I explored whether anything in particular had happened at school to make her feel left out, and she said no.  I'm not surprised -- Maya is really popular in her class.  When I last visited during recess, Maya was mobbed by kids who wanted to play with her.  She was the undisputed leader in some game involving spies and kids pretending to be animals;  all the kids ran to her to seek approval for whatever animal and spy superpower they'd concocted!  There haven't been any more incidents with the little boy who said Maya couldn't sit next to him since she was Chinese.

The conversation kind of petered away, as they often do, redirected to the need to get to ballet class on time.  But I made a note that we needed to talk again, and that I had a book on the bookshelf that might be good to read.  This evening, I finally got around to pulling it out -- An American Face, about a little boy adopted from Korea who thought that when he received his American citizenship he'd also get his "American face."  He doesn't like his flat nose or slanted eyes or light brown skin.  The ultimate lesson in the book is one I love, that lots of different faces are "American."

Maya liked that the boy felt like she did, being the only one with an Asian face in his kindergarden class.  But she ultimately said that the boy was silly, because it doesn't matter that people look different, that they all have the same heart. It sounded like a rote lesson, not really something she internalized. so I reiterated that I understood how she felt about being different.  When we were in China for five months in 2007, my "American face" made me very different, and sometimes that made me feel very uncomfortable.  Maya's kind heart was quick to defend me -- "But I like your American face!"  That gave me the opportunity to tell her, feature by feature, from the little peak in her eyebrows to the point of her chin, how much I love her Chinese face!

I know this won't be our last conversation on this point -- it certainly wasn't our first.  But I'm always glad that my girls are willing to talk about their feelings.  And I'm glad I hoard all manner of books to open (or re-open) the door to such topics. 

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Race-Based Adoption Fees

Here's another issue that the public should be made aware of during National Adoption Awareness Month:
Joe and Becky Ketarkus said money was not a factor in how they approached adoption, but they said they were stunned to learn of a stratified fee system in which white children cost thousands of dollars more to adopt than black children.

"It made me furious that free-market economics would be applied to babies," said Joe Ketarkus.

Beth Hall, co-author of "Inside Transracial Adoption," said race-based adoption fees are "inherently racist and unethical" but common. Such a system has the unfortunate side effect of discouraging some families of color from adopting children because they find the system insulting, Hall said.
I've blogged more about the issue here. When did you first become aware of this stratified fee structure that values children according to their race?  What did you think about it?  Do you think it's an appropriate recognition of the reality of "hard-to-place" children?  Or does it reinforce racism?

Friday, November 12, 2010

Chinese Projects

Yesterday after school the girls both had projects to finish.  Zoe had to finish her poster for Chinese School:
It's for the annual speech contest, so not only did she have to write it all in Chinese characters and pinyin, she has to "speak it" in Mandarin and then in English.  The first third of the poster is about her age, grade, level in Chinese School, and that she likes Science but doesn't like Math.  The middle third is about food and sports -- she likes rice, but not duck; she likes swimming, but not football.  The final third is about what she did on summer vacation.  She didn't want to write about Florida, she wanted to share all about Chinese Heritage Camp. 

Not to be outdone, Maya had to finish a cute Thanksgiving project for school.  The kids were given the outline of a turkey, and were to disguise the turkey so he would make it through Thanksgiving without being eaten!
Maya's idea was to turn him into a panda bear, since surely no one would be having roast panda for Thanksgiving dinner!  She tore up miniscule bits of white and black tissue paper and glued them on, so he'd look like he had fur. She gave him a sprig of bamboo from our backyard and a Chinese coin necklace (raiding my scrapbooking supplies to do so!).  In the accompanying description, Maya wrote: "I am NOT a turkey because turkeys do not have fur. I am NOT a turkey because turkeys are not black and white. I am NOT a turkey because turkeys do not eat bamboo.  I am NOT a turkey because turkeys are not from China!"

As you can see from their smiles, the girls are quite proud of their projects.  As you can tell from the fact that I'm posting about them, so am I!

Thursday, November 11, 2010

The BIG 5-0!

Happy Birthday to MEEEE
Happy Birthday to MEEE
Happy Birthday dear MEE-EEEE
Happy Birthday to MEEE!

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Adopting Out the Children of Illegal Immigrants

Remember the mother in Mississippi who lost custody of her child for a year after hospital workers discovered she was an illegal immigrant? Have you read about this new case? An undocumented immigrant from Guatemala had her parental rights terminated and her child adopted by another family when she was swept up in an immigration raid and jailed. The Missouri Court of Appeals reversed the trial court's termination and order of adoption, and the Missouri Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the case yesterday.

Here are the facts from the Court of Appeals opinion:
The only evidence concerning the care of Child was the testimony of a parent educator with Parents as Teachers for Carthage R-9 Schools, Laura Davenport ("Ms.Davenport"), and what Respondents heard about Child from others. No evidence was obtained from Mother or any of her family members at the transfer of custody hearing or at the adoption hearing. We recount the following facts as they were presented to the trial court:

At the time Mother was arrested, Child was staying with Mother's brother ("Brother"). A few days after Mother's arrest, Brother gave Child to Mother's sister ("Sister") and brother-in-law. Unable to care for Child full-time, Sister sought babysitting services through Ms. Davenport, who referred Sister to Jennifer and Oswaldo Velazco ("the Velazco family"), local clergy of a Hispanic church in Carthage, Missouri.

It was at this point that Sister relied on the Velazco family to help provide childcare for Child. At first, the Velazco family would pick Child up in the morning and Sister would bring Child back home in the evening. This arrangement lasted for a few weeks, when it was decided that instead of shuffling Child back and forth, Child would stay with the Velazco family during the week and Sister would pick him up on Fridays for the weekend. As of September of 2007, Child was still living with Sister on the weekends.

In September of 2007, Ms. Davenport visited Mother at the St. Clair County Jail to see if Mother was willing to let Child be adopted. Mother responded that she did not want Child to be adopted. Yet, on September 24, 2007, the Velazco family contacted Respondents about adopting Child and started granting them visitations with Child. The Velazco family knew Respondents' brother and sister-in-law and they sought out Respondents as a potential adopting family. After ten days of visitation and one overnight visit, Child came to live with Respondents full-time on October 5, 2007.

On October 5, 2007, before the Velazco family informed Sister that Child would not be returned to her, Respondents filed their Petition to adopt Child and terminate Mother's parental rights ancillary to the adoption. The Summons and Petition for transfer of custody, termination of parental rights, and adoption was served on Mother on October 15, 2007, a mere three days before the transfer of custody hearing.

Respondents argue that because Mother was served and did not appear at the transfer of custody hearing, she waived her right to argue improper service. However, a closer review of the record demonstrates that the transfer of custody hearing was not scheduled until October 17, 2007 – two days after Mother was served with the Summons and Petition. Additionally, the caption on the Notice of Hearing indicates that only Joseph Hensley, Respondents’ attorney, and Jamey Garrity, the guardian ad litem ("GAL"), received notice of the transfer of custody hearing. Mother was not indicated in the caption and no attorney was noticed on her behalf. The body of the notice of hearing document tells the noticed parties to inform their clients. Thus, it is clear that Mother received no notice of the transfer of custody hearing.

Mother was not present or represented by counsel at the transfer of custody hearing on October 18, 2007; counsel was not appointed for her until December 3, 2007, almost two months after the custody of Child had been transferred to Respondents. Child was never in the jurisdiction of the Juvenile Division of the Circuit Court. The court heard evidence from Respondents about their circumstances and how Child came to be a part of their lives.

During the hearing, Respondents presented a home study that had been completed to assess their fitness to serve as foster parents. The home study addressed Respondents' strengths and weaknesses, along with their backgrounds, which included concerns about S.M.'s criminal history and the involvement of M.M.'s brother, who M.M. claimed had sexually abused her as a child. The assessment made two recommendations before Respondents could be licensed foster parents: (1) create a safer home environment for children because Respondents lived in a basement apartment; and (2) further assessment from the Children's Division representatives regarding the presence of M.M.'s brother in her life. There is no evidence of compliance with either of these requirements in the record, other than M.M.'s verbal confirmation that "everything" was approved.

The GAL recommended transfer of custody, stating that "there was an emergency situation in that nobody had the ability to care for [Child] . . . so maybe with this transfer of custody [Respondents will] be able to take [Child] to the doctor or get him his needed shots or checkups." The court granted Respondents care and custody of Child pending further proceedings.

The adoption hearing was held on October 7, 2008. At that hearing, Respondents' counsel offered and the court admitted a letter he sent to Mother that was returned refused and M.M. testified that Respondents' attorney sent letters to Mother in jail. Additionally, a letter from the court advising Mother about her first appointment of counsel was also returned refused. The court later withdrew that appointment, and it was at this point that Respondents hired Aldo Dominguez ("Mr. Dominguez") to represent Mother in the termination of parental rights and adoption proceedings. Other than the two letters sent by Respondents, no effort was made to locate Mother or to ensure she had knowledge of the termination and adoption proceeding. Furthermore, there is no evidence that the GAL attempted to find Mother or her family.

The termination and adoption hearing lasted for a total of 106 minutes. A substantial portion of the hearing was devoted to Respondents' purported fitness as parents for Child and no evidence was presented on behalf of Mother other than a letter indicating:

"I have suffered too much by knowing nothing about my little one, asking God to take care of him for me and let me be reunited with him soon. Please, Mr. Dominguez, look for the means to send my son [Child] with my family in Guatemala. This is the telephone number of my sister in Guatemala, I spoke to her and she will welcome him in my country."

Mother was represented by counsel, who was paid for by Respondents, and she was not present. Additionally, there was no report or investigation into Mother's background to show why she was unfit to be a parent or why termination of parental rights was in Child's best interests. In fact, the court admits that "[n]ot much is known about [Mother] except what could be discovered through her plea agreement and the testimony of [Ms.]Davenport[.]"

The court found that Mother "abandoned" Child, as used in sections 453.040(7) and 211.447.2(2)(b), RSMo Cum. Supp. 2007, when she went to prison without making provisions for care of Child.[ fn. 10. It is undisputed that Mother left Child in the custody of her family. There is no evidence that she was given an opportunity to make further arrangements if her family was not able to care for Child.]

In addition, the court stated that Mother had no contact with Child nor attempted to communicate with him from the time she was arrested. The court had two letters from Mother in its file. One was a letter dated October 28, 2007, indicating that Mother did not want Child adopted. The other one was a letter sent to Respondents' attorney, according to the testimony of S.M., on September 16, 2008, indicating that Mother did not want Child adopted. No evidence was presented at trial to show whether Mother had contacted her family about Child or whether she was capable of providing support for Child while she was imprisoned. Additionally, nothing in the record indicates that Mother knew how to contact Child or where to find him once he was placed with Respondents – last she heard, Child was still being cared for by Sister.
 
Respondents asserted that their contact information was on the pleadings so Mother could find them; however, it was clear from the testimony at trial that Mother did not speak English. There was no clear evidence whether Mother had a translator available to interpret the documents for her or to help her understand the gravity of the situation.
 
When considering Mother's present circumstances, the court noted that Mother was unable to offer proof that she would be employable in Guatemala, had a home there, or had any way to care for Child, "leaving the court to believe that [Mother] would be unable to provide adequate food, clothing, or shelter to [Child] in her physical custody in the future." Moreover, the court stated that "[Mother's] lifestyle, that of smuggling herself into a country illegally and committing crimes in this country is not a lifestyle that can provide any stability for a child. A child cannot be educated in this way, always in hiding or on the run." There was no investigative report about Mother's ability to parent, and there was no evidence to indicate that Mother was an unfit parent. The only evidence presented on behalf of Mother was a letter from her, indicating that she had someone on stand-by ready and willing to take responsibility for Child until Mother was released from prison and deported to Guatemala. The court indicated, "[t]he only certainties in [Mother's] future is that she will remain incarcerated until next year, and that she will be deported thereafter." The court stated that "[Mother] appeared to put forth no effort to locate [Child] and, in fact, should have known where [Child] was."
 
The court granted Respondents' petition to adopt Child and terminated Mother's parental rights.
So what do you think?  Are you troubled by the termination of parental rights on these facts?  BTW, the required constitutional standard for termination of parental rights is "clear and convincing evidence."  Do you think we have that here?  Are you troubled by the fact that the mother is represented by counsel paid for by the adoptive parents?  Could there be a conflict of interest in that?  The mother ignored letters sent to her, didn't she?  Does that prove abandonment?  But where's the proof she got the letters?  What about the judge's "lifestyle" argument?  Do you think the adoptive parents are fit, based on the record presented?  That the biological mother is unfit, based on the record presented?  Do you think the fact that the mother is talking about taking an American citizen child to that backwater, Guatemala, is influencing the trial judge?  How much of this case is about race, class, nationalism and the illegal immigration debate in America?

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

A hunger, marrow-deep

In honor of National Adoption Awareness Month:

"In all of us there is a hunger, marrow-deep, to know our heritage- to know who we are and where we have come from. Without this enriching knowledge, there is a hollow yearning. No matter what our attainments in life, there is still a vacuum, an emptiness, and the most disquieting loneliness. "


— Alex Haley, Roots

Monday, November 8, 2010

The Cole Babies

See what I mean about raising awareness?  There are these bits of adoption history in the U.S. we've never heard about.  I knew about Georgia Tann, but Katherine Cole is news to me:
Cyn Bird grabbed a torn piece of notebook paper to scribble the secrets spilling from her mother's mouth as she neared death: The mysterious Miami doctor named Katherine Cole who delivered and supposedly sold babies to couples. The phone call on Jan. 12, 1962, that a baby girl with sky blue eyes was available. The $2,500 cash price tag.

After 46 years, Bird had learned the stunning truth about her birth from her mother. Bird was adopted. Illegally.

"How do you wake up at my age and realize you have no idea who you really are?'' asks Bird, a New Jersey wife, mother and artist who discovered her adoption in March 2008, four months before her mother's death. "I am still trying to wrap my head around this.''

She turned to the Internet and found others like her. The people of this new community even had a name for themselves: Cole babies.

In what authorities call one of the most haunting, widespread cases of illegal adoptions in Florida history, Cole reportedly placed more than 1,000 babies, most without legal documentation, out of her two-story Southwest Eighth Street clinic from the 1930s to the 1960s. She died in 1981, leaving no records and without ever admitting the full scale of the shadowy operation that created three generations of Cole babies struggling to piece together their identities. For most, the discovery was triggered by a revelation and a birth certificate on which Cole listed the adoptive parents as the birth parents.
More than 1,000 babies illegally adopted.  Wow.

In Case You've Been Living in a Cave, Snowed In Without Newspapers, and Your Cable Was Knocked Out and Your Antenna Knocked Down, and You Just Had Your Internet Service Restored But You Can't Remember Your Facebook Password, Twitter is Over Capacity, Though You Can Finally Catch Up on Your Blog Reading, Here's the BIG News You Missed: November is Adoption Awareness Month

November is National Adoption Month, and we're asked everywhere to "celebrate" adoption.  I admit, I have a hard time with that. I acknowledge that, as an adoptive parent, I'm the only one in the adoption triad who didn't come to adoption through tragedy.  How can I "celebrate" the tragedy that made my children available for adoption?  But I can certainly accept a national adoption AWARENESS month, which happens to be the official name.  There are LOTS of things people need to be aware of when it comes to adoption.

I thought I'd go through Adoptive Families Magazine's 30 Ways to Celebrate National Adoption Month article, and suggest some ways that their ideas could be tweaked a bit to increase awareness, both inside your family and out:

2. Ask your library to display adoption books to commemorate National Adoption Awareness Month.

Here are some books to suggest -- books from the important perspective of adopted persons, and books that reveal a history of adoption that is often ignored:

The Language of Blood by Jane Jeong Trenka
Fugitive Visions by Jane Jeong Trenka
Outsiders Within: Writing on Transracial Adoption
Orphan Train: Placing Out in America
Kinship by Design: A History of Adoption in the Modern United States
The Girls Who Went Away by Ann Fessler

5. Find out where your representatives at the state and national level stand on adoption issues. Write to them regarding your concerns.

You can click here to find out your state's position on adoptee access to original birth certificates.  Chances are, your state does not allow such access since only 6 states do.  The American Adoption Congress provides lots of online materials to help you inform legislators on this issue.

7. Create a scrapbook with your child. Talk about significant events as you record them together.

Make sure you include significant events -- such a BIRTH! -- that occurred before you and  your child met. Here's a link about adoption lifebooks to get your started.

9. Find an adult adoptee or a person of color—a coach, a teacher, or a babysitter—who can serve as a mentor for your child. Arrange for them to get together monthly.

If your area is not very diverse, you need to act intentionally to bring adults who share your child's race into their lives.  Pediatrician, dentist, eye doctor -- given a choice, choose the one who shares your child's race.  Getting to know adult adopted persons can be a great help in letting kids know someone older and wiser who can listen to their problems.

11. Spend some time celebrating your child’s heritage.

The internet is a wonderful place to find recipes, traditions, folklore, about your child's birth country.

13. Give an adoption talk at school.

Keep it real, keep it age-appropriate, and talk as much as  you can about how families can be different, and that's OK.

14. Pass along an adoption-related article to another adoptive parent or friend.

Here are a few I'd suggest:

The Lie We Love by E.J. Graff
The Baby Business:  Policy Proposals for Fairer Practice by E.J. Graff
Anatomy of an Adoption Crisis by E.J. Graff

I'd also suggest that  you share blog links -- especially adult adoptee and birth mother blogs -- with your adoptive parent friends.  It's so important for all adoptive parents to read from all perspectives, especially from those that might be different from their own.  Check out the links in the blog roll to your right.  Send your favorites via email, Facebook and/or Twitter to your friends.

20. NAT IONAL ADOPTION DAY! Courts across the country will finalize thousands of adoptions
today.

These are adoptions from foster care.  If you are an attorney, consider volunteering.  Remember, courts are open to the public.  Feel free to visit your courthouse and watch the finalizations.  This can be a great experience for kids, especially if they were too young to remember their own, or if they are experiencing anxiety about how permanent their adoption is.  You can show them how the judge makes a family a family forever.  Click here to check for events in your area.

21. Develop a family ritual to show thanks for your family and the special way you’ve found one another AND 27. Together, light a candle in honor of your child’s birthparents. Turn off the lights and hold hands as you watch the flame.

I love family rituals, and combining 21 and 27 acknowledges that your child's birth family is part of your family.  For some suggestions of family rituals, check out Creating Ceremonies: Innovative Ways to Meet Adoption Challenges.

I also think rituals are extremely important when a child's birth parents are unknown.  Rituals can give them a concrete presence in a child's life.  My kids, for example, write notes to birth moms on Mother's Day, and burn the notes so that the smoke can carry good wishes to them in China. 

28. Make holiday crafts that incorporate designs from your child’s heritage.

Again, the internet is your friend here!

30. Make a donation in your child’s or birthmother’s name to an adoption-related charity or organization.

Tw of my favorites are family preservation funds;  after all, the only way to solve the orphan crisis is to prevent kids from being orphaned in the first place.  So check out:

The Unity Fund from Love Without Boundaries

The Family Preservation Initiative from Ethica

So get out there and do your part for adoption awareness -- awareness of ALL the issues in adoption, the good and bad, the happy and sad.  That's the awareness the public needs, that's the awareness you need to help your child.

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Looking for you

From the Times of India, an article about the difficulties of searching for birth family in India:
Aarti would like to meet her birth mother. It can be a secret meeting without the birth mother's family involved, if that is what the birth mother wishes. Aarti only wants to meet her birth mother — no obligation..." These three short sentences say it all. Urgent, hesitant, hopeful and understanding, the message is almost apologetic.

It is on an adoption website and is one of a dozen such appeals on the Net from Indians who were adopted by foreigners. All of them are on a root search. This means adoptees looking for their biological mother. A few have photographs tacked on, perhaps in the hope that some family resemblance will jog memory somewhere. Others provide little details such as "the only recognizable difference I had was ear tags, extra skin near my earlobes, at birth", or "I have a brown birthmark on my right forearm, above my wrist". Many admit they are unsure about how old they are, as in "American doctors say I am about 33 years old."

Searching for one's biological parents is a complicated affair in India.

* * *

A new set of draft guidelines have been prepared by the Central Adoption Resource Agency (CARA). Even though provision for root search has been included in these guidelines, it's not certain whether things will ever improve. A contradiction within this draft will make it tough. While it accepts that the adopted child should be given "as much information as possible" by agencies, and that "in case of unwed mothers, the same shall be done after obtaining their willingness," the guidelines threaten to de-register any recognized agency that reveals "confidential information on the background of adoptees... to any outside agency or individual." Activists fear that heavy-duty confidentiality clauses in the root search programme will make it easier for suspect agencies to cover up information on trafficking.

Saturday, November 6, 2010

The Big 1-0


One decade.  Double digits.  The BIG 1-0!  I can't believe my baby Zoe is 10 years old today! How could she have grown so much since I brought her home yesterday?!

 She's such a mix of little girl and little lady -- she loved the very-tween robe from my sister, with "Girls Rule" all over it, and loved just as much the schoolhouse furniture set for her doll house, which she still loves to play with.  She loved the silver hoop earrings from me and the stuffed big-eyed penguin from her sister. She loved the very-grownup art set from Mimi, with real artist's paints, and loved the minivan for her dollhouse dolls to tool around in. And you can see she still loves her Baby Joy, which she got on her second birthday, so Baby Joy needed to be in on the gift-opening since she apparently turned 8 today!

Zoe says being 10 feels just like being 9, but I have to admit it makes me feel old!  Zoe was really tickled when she was little and figured out I was 40 years older than her:  "When I'm 6 you'll be 46, and when I'm 7 you'll be 47, and when I'm 8 you'll be 48, and when I'm 9 you'll be 49, and when I'm 10 you'll be 40-10. . . ."  Yikes!  40-10 just sneaked up on me (I've got 5 more days). . . .

Turning 9 lead to lots of thought of birth family for Zoe, the perennial "Do you think they're thinking about me today?" question.  This year, she seems to be in a different phase.  My mentions of her birth parents have been ignored.  She's not biting at any of my overtures in that direction.  She's been changing to conversation to discussing her adoption instead. That's fine, but it doesn't prevent me from thinking of her birth mother today. 

Friday, November 5, 2010

Talking Adoption to the First Grade

I was invited to talk about adoption to Maya's first grade class today.  Maya was really excited as we picked out some books to read and decided on what we wanted to say.  She loved being my helper as we explained adoption to her class! 

From an article at Adoptive Families Magazine, How I Explained Adoption to the First Grade, I stole the idea of bringing a doll to class, and from my friend LisaLew I stole the idea of having the class act out an adoption.

I started out asking the kids if they knew what adoption was.  Just about everyone in the class raised their hands, and I started pointing at a few.  The first was a little girl I knew was adopted from China, and she said, "Adoption is when a mom and dad want a baby and they go to another country to get it."  The next said, "When a lady isn't married and has a baby, she has to give it up for adoption." [Wonder where he heard that?!]  Maya said, "When birth parents have a baby and can't take care of it, they take it to an orphanage, and the orphanage looks for a forever family for the baby." 

So, they each had a little piece of the story of adoption, and I wanted to affirm what they knew and also deepen their understanding.  And part of a real understanding of adoption is realizing that there are birth parents who relinquish a child before a child is adopted into a new family.  So often the focus on adoption starts with the adoptive parents, especially for kids' understanding of adoption.

The kids have been talking about baptism and bringing in posters with baptism pictures (Maya did an adoption poster instead, and that's the photo above)  of them as tiny infants, so I talked to them as "baby experts," who knew a lot about babies.  Their confidence in their knowledge of all things baby was pretty funny! I pulled a baby doll out of my bag, and introduced them to "Baby Joy." I asked them what Baby Joy needed to grow up healthy and happy, and they had lots of ideas -- milk, baby food, diapers, clothes, shelter, lots of sleep (and the crib to do it in!), warmth, love, and being good Catholic school students, baptism!  I asked whose job it was to give babies these things, and they listed parents first, and then grandparents, aunts & uncles, etc.  So I asked what would happen if parents couldn't take care of a baby or provide the baby with what it needs.  The class immediately said adoption.

I had Maya choose two kids to be the baby's first parents, and they stepped up to the front of the room to hold Baby Joy.  The "mom" was the other little girl adopted from China.  We talked about some reasons why birth parents might not be able to take care of a baby -- too young, too poor, too sick.  Mom clearly didn't want to give up Baby Joy -- she said, "But if only one of the birth parents is sick, maybe a friend could help take care of the baby."  I agreed with her that sometimes all birth parents need is a little help, and said that sometimes there wasn't anyone who could or would help.  So she said goodbye to the baby, and handed her over to the two girls Maya picked to be the nannies at the orphanage.  It was actually quite poignant.

While the nannies took care of the baby, patting and rocking her, Maya picked two kids to be the adoptive parents and one kid to be the social worker.  We talked about the social worker's job, to find a good family for Baby Joy.  The adoptive parents had to be able to take care of the baby, and promise to love her and take care of her forever.  So the social worker asked the prospective adoptive parents:  "Do you have money?  Do you have a house? Do you promise to love the baby forever?"  They said yes, and I said they could go to the orphanage to get their baby.  As the new parents approached the nannies, it was so funny! The social worker swooped in and took the baby from the nanny and handed her to the adoptive mom! I thought it was amazing that, not having a real clue about what a social worker was, a first grader would feel she needed to be the one to hand over the baby!

After our little play, I read two of our favorite adoption books -- Over the Moon and the Best Single Mom in the World.  The kids were so quiet and attentive, I was amazed!  They like them, too!  I like them because they both mention birth moms, and I wanted to read the single mom one to talk about the other way our family is different. 

I asked the class if they noticed anything different about Maya and me.  By this time, Maya is plastered to my side, beaming at being the center of attention, and she put her cheek to mine -- just in case they couldn't figure out how we are different!  It's clear that we don't give children permission to point out racial differences, because the first responses were tentative -- Maya was from China, they said.  I explained that Maya was Chinese-American and I was Caucasian; gotta give them some vocabulary before they can identify difference.  We talked about whether families had to look alike, and whether you can love people who don't look like you. 

We then talked about how families are different.  Some have only moms, some have only dads, some have both moms and dads, and some have both moms and dads, but the moms and dads don't live together.  I then got to hear about every family arrangement in the class that didn't follow the mom-and-dad formula!  Yes, in case you wondered, your first grader WILL tell anyone who asks that mom and dad live together, but don't sleep in the same bed!  LOL!!!

All in all, I think I managed to explain adoption in an age-appropriate way to the first grade.  Baby Joy was a big hit, as was the role play.  Maya loved every minute of it, and the other little girl adopted from China was quite proud to announce she was adopted, too.  I think Maya is very lucky to have a teacher who is open to such discussion in the classroom.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Speaking to the identity of Chinese children in America

From the Washington Post, an article about the growth of Chinese language schools, and the role of adoptive families in that growth:
Abby Newell's adoptive parents have been preparing for her "birth tour" for years. They have attended Chinese culture camp in Silver Spring, decorated their Fairfax home like a Shanghai apartment and - most important, they say - enrolled Abby in Mandarin classes on the weekend.


The goal is for her to land in China sometime in the next few years with a sense of her own complex identity: She is both an 8-year-old girl from suburban Virginia and a child whose birth mother left her in a rural Chinese outpost with a note pinned to her saying, "I can't keep this child."

Thousands of American parents who adopted girls near the peak of the Chinese adoption boom earlier this decade are facing similar dilemmas as their children reach school age. Increasingly, they are turning to weekend classes in rented public schools or storefronts taken over by bare-bones Chinese language programs.

"We've always believed that language is the key to culture - to Abby's heritage," said her mother, Robin Lelyveld Newell. "These classes aren't just about fluency. They're about identity."
Each of my girls started Saturday Chinese School at age 3, the youngest age the school will accept.  It has definitely been a good thing for both girls.  I agree that language is the key to culture, and that we're getting more than language out of the exercise, we're also getting cultural competence.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

The Adoption Constellation

Adoption Mosaic, a support organization, which has a terrific blog, now has a monthly magazine!  Consistent with their mission to bring together everyone in the adoption "constellation," birth family members, adoptees, adoptive parents, adoption professionals, the magazine has articles from all these perspectives.  The first issue is available online, and afterwards the subscription will be $25 per year.  Some of the article you'll find in this issue:
Ask Astrid

An advice column from adult transracial adoptee Astrid, responding to an adoptive father who wants to know what he could have done while raising his now-adult daughter to better understand her and her birth family's experiences.  Astrid shares this anecdote:

Recently my mother and I had a conversation that left me very proud. During a recent visit my mother mentioned that, when she attended a workshop of mine on transracial adoption, she heard me say something along the lines of “it is important to acknowledge your child’s birth family and to remember that you are raising someone else’s child.” She said, “until that very moment I had never thought of it that way and I think this is one of the most important things that parents should hear.” I couldn’t believe my ears. I wanted to both hug her and shake her! Really, this was the first time she had ever thought of this, and wow, how wonderful that she was talking about it with me! I knew this didn’t mean she had never thought about my birth mother before but, rather, this was a new way of thinking for her. She attended a workshop and was willing to step outside her box and listen to what I had to say as an adoption professional, not as her daughter.

It's All About the Hair by Amy K. Hall

Like it or not, our children are a reflection of us. Naturally, we want that reflection to be positive regarding how a child behaves and treats others. But a child’s appearance—or how their appearance reflects on us as parents—isn’t something most people spend a lot of time thinking or worrying about. That is unless you’re a transracial adoptive parent, and then appearance seems to move to the top of the list whether we want it to or not. For me, that means hair care.

Humanizing Humanity by Maureen

“Mom, please, please, make Dad change his mind. Please let me come home with my baby, just until I find a place of my own. I know I agreed to the adoption, but I just can’t give her away. She is so beautiful. I need to keep her Mom. Please help me.”


My father didn’t change his mind. My mother was quietly powerless. I was not welcome to come home with my first born daughter. My social worker told me if I kept her, I would have to put her in foster care anyway, because I was going to have to find a job and wouldn’t be able to look after her. Plus it would be a devastating disappointment to the family who planned to adopt my baby. I could think of no one to turn to.

Interview:  Dr. Richard Boas

Dr. Richard Boas is an adoptive father, founded the Korean Unwed Mothers Support Network (KUMSN) which works to educate, inform and promote discussion about the difficulties facing unwed mothers and their children in order to elevate their economic, political and social potential in Korean society.   From the interview:

I met a group of pregnant women who had already signed away their unborn children. I had always believed in fairness and social justice, and had treated my medical patients with respect, educating them and actively involving them in decisions that affected their health and lives. But these women were powerless, marginalized, and stripped of motherhood before delivering. I also visited children who had been relinquished by their mothers, which brought all of that into focus more fully. Imagine holding an infant, days old, and realizing that this child’s mother is capable, loving, and not far away.


I discovered that most of these women did not want to give up their children for adoption. But they felt that they had to due to economic and societal pressures. It hit me hard that my daughter’s mother, years before, had done the same thing. She loved her child as much as I did, gave her up under pressure, and would likely never see her again. I realized that these adoptions were about the child and the adoptive parents. The mother was left out of the equation. This was a wrong I wanted to correct.
There are other really great articles, too. I hope you'll read the whole thing -- I gobbled it up in one sitting, and immediately subscribed!

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Pressuring Countries on Adoption Can Lead to Trafficking

So says Geoffrey Shannon, the newly appointed chairman of Ireland's Hague Convention Central Authority:
Putting pressure on countries to sign up to adoption agreements could potentially lead to child trafficking, a childcare expert warned yesterday.

Geoffrey Shannon, the chairman of the new Adoption Authority of Ireland, yesterday stressed that it was "hugely important" to avoid any links between humanitarian aid agreements and payments in the adoption of children from other regions.

The first major overhaul since adoptions began in Ireland in 1953 saw the appointment yesterday of the new seven-member board and the long-awaited ratification of the Hague Convention.

* * *

Mr Shannon stressed the importance of a "clear demarcation line" between humanitarian aid and adoptions.

"Putting pressure on jurisdictions to enter into agreement is actually contrary to the spirit of Hague," the special rapporteur on child protection said.

"What we should not forget is that where we put pressure on jurisdictions to enter into agreements that has the potential to lead to child trafficking."
Australia takes the same position that a country cannot tie humanitarian aid and adoption together, having suspended adoption with Ethiopia because the Ethiopian government requested that the Australian government provide community development aid as a condition to continue adoption placements to Australia.

I had a huge disagreement with Susan Soon-Keum Cox of Holt Adoption Agency on this point during discussion of the Hague Convention at the St. John's Conference on Adoption last month.  She feels not just that such agreements are allowed under the Hague Convention, but that countries should require countries and agencies to provide humanitarian assistance in order to be licensed to do international adoptions in their countries.  She sees it as "giving back" to those countries.  I see it as cash for kids, and clearly violative of the Hague Convention.  Yes, I think countries and agencies should give humanitarian assistance, and I certainly admire the scope and depth of Holt's humanitarian programs in the countries from which it places children, but for a sending country to make it a condition of placing children is a problem, in my opinion. I also see it as coercive for a receiving country to condition their humanitarian aid on the sending country sending them children.

Monday, November 1, 2010

State Department Briefing on International Adoption

To mark the start of National Adoption Month, Special Advisor for Children's Issues Ambassador Susan Jacobs gave a briefing about international adoption.  Pretty pro forma stuff, but brief mentions of Ethiopia, Nepal & Haiti:
One of the countries that we are working with is Ethiopia. The number of adoptions from Ethiopia continues to increase and it now ranks second in the world behind China in the number of children who are adopted from Ethiopia to the United States. At the beginning of September, I was pleased to accompany Senator Mary Landrieu and U.S. Agency for International Development Special Advisor for Orphans and Vulnerable Children Gary Newton to Ethiopia. We visited orphanages, child care centers, and other organizations and met with government leaders. One of the results already of this visit is greater cooperation between the United States, other countries that adopt from Ethiopia, and nongovernmental organizations as we work with the Government of Ethiopia to help them improve their child welfare system and to make sure that adoptions are transparent and honest.

The United States joined a number of other countries – in fact, all the countries that were then doing adoptions in Nepal, in suspending any new adoption cases based on abandonment. We recognize the heartache experienced by parents whose cases have not yet been processed, and they are waiting for the completion of their investigations. We are especially mindful of the effects that any delay in an investigation may have in the life of a child, and for prospective adoption parents who are looking for a conclusion to their case and the ability to bring their child home.

However, investigations are necessary to ensure that the children sought for adoption are indeed orphans and eligible for inter-country adoption. A joint U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service and State Department team traveled to Nepal in an effort to determine how to address the existing cases. Officials at our Embassy in Kathmandu are making every effort to expedite these cases.

After the devastating earthquake in Haiti, the Departments of Homeland Security, Health and Human Services, and State coordinated efforts to ensure the safety and welfare of orphans who are in the process of being adopted by American families. Through the extraordinary commitment of the United States Government in Haiti, their personnel in Haiti and here in the United States, we united over 1,000 children with their adoptive families. During the crisis, 12 children were also brought from Haiti to the United States who had not previously been matched with families here. Health and Human Services, Homeland Security, and State have been working closely with the Government of Haiti to ensure the welfare of children and respect for Haitian laws and procedures. A delegation from the three agencies traveled to Haiti about four weeks ago to work with the Haitian Government to resolve these cases.
More details about the 12 Haitian children came out in the very brief Q & A session:
QUESTION: I have a question. You mentioned the 12 Haitian children who were brought here and had not been matched. Where do those cases stand?

* * *

AMBASSADOR JACOBS: We sent a team down there to meet with the Haitian officials and with the parents of these children, and we expect that these cases will be resolved very soon.

QUESTION: Resolved in what way? Will the children go back?

AMBASSADOR JACOBS: Resolved in whether the parents want to relinquish the children so that they can be adopted in the United States or --

QUESTION: So the parents have been identified?

AMBASSADOR JACOBS: Oh, yes. I mean, and the children have – were in contact with their parents throughout this process.

QUESTION: Okay.

AMBASSADOR JACOBS: They’re in a very safe, loving atmosphere. I have been in touch with the social worker there. So the children are well-protected and well-cared for. But it’s up to the parents to decide whether or not they want to relinquish these children for adoption. And if they don’t, we will send back the children whose parents want them returned.
Doesn't that seem backwards?  Shouldn't we return them to their parents in Haiti, and THEN ask whether they want to place them for adoption?!

There were other questions about Russian and Guatemalan adoption, though not very forthcoming answers. Click the link above to read the whole thing.

Costumes for Minority Kids: Is it more difficult?

OK, I posted about racist costumes, which is basically any time a white person dresses up as a minority person, really.  But what about costumes for minority kids?  Are there issues and pitfalls to be aware of?

I'm curious as to what y'all make of this -- Maya got to wear her costume to the ballet class before Halloween.  That's a yearly tradition at her ballet school, and the students are still required to wear the usual pink tights and ballet shoes.  After class, Maya asked me if she had to wear tights with her costume on Halloween.  I told her it would be up to her, unless it was cold, and then she'd need to wear them for warmth.

When it came time to get ready for trick-or-treating, I told Maya it was her choice whether to wear tights since it was plenty warm.  Maya declared she wanted to wear her pink tights, since it "makes my legs look more like Dorothy's."  Of course, Dorothy doesn't wear tights in the movie.  So my thought is that Maya was saying wearing tights made her legs look Caucasian, like Dorothy.

How much "race-bending" are you comfortable with for your non-Caucasian children for Halloween?  As Cinderella, would your Chinese child wear a blonde wig?  Would you put your non-white child in "white-face" to be Harry Potter? Would you paint her face white to be a ghost?  A zombie?  Is that different from painting her face green to be a witch?  If  your Chinese child wants to be a farmer, to you put her in Howdy-Doody freckles?  Or is she simply a Chinese farmer?  And does that mean a "coolie" hat?!

The questions are difficult, it seems to me, because the line between dress-up and "wanting to be white" is so thin for minority kids. And the line between "wanting to be white" and self-loathing is even thinner.

Have you had to deal with these issues with your child?  I've always said no to the blonde-wig thing, but that's about all I've had to address (except for the "Dorothy's legs" thing this year!). And yes, Maya wore her tights. So where do you draw the line?

Sunday, October 31, 2010

Happy Halloween!

As you can see, my two -- Wendy Darling from Peter Pan and Dorothy from the Wizard of Oz -- went trick-or-treating with a Greek goddess, a pirate and Eyore. I hope your crew of tricksters had as much fun as we did, because we had a ball!

Saturday, October 30, 2010

Is Your Halloween Costume Racist?

From Gawker:
Some Halloween costumes offend the senses. Some are just plain offensive. Here's a handy guide to 12 racially charged Halloween costumes, whether you can get away with wearing them, and what to do if you accidentally bought a racist one.

* * *

'Asian Doll'

Whereas geishas occupy a grey area (Oscar-winning movies have that effect), mishmash pan-Asian "doll" costumes get a resounding "nay." Ditto "Asian Costume," "Sexy Asian Girl," and this "Chinese Take Out Costume." (That last one is just begging for gross jokes about "eating out.") Do not wear these costumes. Possible exception: You are an Asian female who likes to spend Halloween confronting fetishistic creeps and making them uncomfortable. Proceed with caution, though, because that joke can backfire.
Gawker also covers other racist costumes -- "Sexy Squaw,"  "Harem Girl," and the like.

Oh, and if you don't want to take advice from Gawker, and want something a little more high-brow, look at this post about racist Halloween costumes from Sociological Images.

And did you know you could find racist Halloween costumes for your pets?

"How come you speak our language?"

We've had beautiful weather the past couple of days;  Friday after school we decided to play on the playground for a while before going home for piano lessons.  There were two boys already playing when we got there, about the same age as my girls, but not from their school since they were in a different uniform.  The kids played well together, but I didn't know afterwards that the boys had lots of questions for the girls.  Zoe doesn't remember exactly how the questioning started, but she said she had to explain adoption to them.  One asked if she spoke some other language, and Zoe told them she spoke Chinese. 

I didn't hear anything about it until we were leaving.  One boy asked, pointing at me, "Is that the girl who adopted you?"  Zoe said, "Yes, she's my mom."  Kinda funny question since both girls had called me Mama as they were playing, one time even running away from the boys while playing tag, and telling them that "Mama" was "base," so they couldn't be tagged while touching me.

Then the last question from the 7-year-old -- "So how come you speak our language?"  Zoe handled that question with aplomb -- "I was just a baby when I came here.  I learned English the same way you did!"

And that was that.

While we were driving home, I asked the girls what they thought of the questions the boys asked.  They said it was OK.  I asked if they get tired of having to answer those kinds of questions all the time, and both said they didn't mind.

They are far more charitable than I am!  I told them sometimes I feel annoyed by all the questions, but they insisted they really didn't mind.  Still, we reviewed the W.I.S.E. Up strategy and I reminded them it was always OK to just Walk away or say It's private.  And it is always their choice whether to Share or Educate.

Friday, October 29, 2010

ABC Picks Up Adoption Drama

From the Hollywood Reporter:
ABC has picked up a drama project from Private Practice star Taye Diggs.

Diggs is partnering with writers Kiersten Van Horne and Cara Haycak for Match, an ensemble drama centering on the ethically complex world of adoption. The show will examine how families are made and broken as the protagonists -- a Los Angeles-based team of lawyers, doctors and caseworkers -- struggle to make dreams come true.
If the drama puts the emphasis on the ethics part instead of the "dreams come true" part, it will be highly dramatic AND valuable.  We'll see.

Thursday, October 28, 2010

BOO!

In time for Halloween, an interesting post from Robert Krulwich at NPR, Chinese & European Monsters Strangely, Eerily Similar:
I couldn't help but notice that with every conceivable shape available, the Chinese came up with monsters that look like the West's monsters. Here’s Toby Lester's list:

The Loppy Ears (who "have such big ears they flop down onto their shoulders")

The Feathered Folk (who "can fly, but not very far")

The Hairy Folk (covered in hair "like a pig")

The Mushroom People (whose aspect was like "a meat fungus")

The Progenyless Folk (a boneless race who, because they eat only air "are clear-headed and live a long time")

So the Chinese imagined Big-Eared monsters and so did the Europeans. The Chinese have air eaters, the Europeans Apple Sniffers .The Chinese have a face-on-my-chest monsters, ditto the Europeans.

* * *

Two thousand plus years ago, Europeans and Chinese had very, very little contact but somehow they imagined a startlingly similar cast of frightening and fantastic creatures.
Go to the article to see drawings of these Chinese and European monsters.

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

The right not to tell

From the New York Times Motherlode blog, a post by adoptive mom Ilie Ruby about sharing -- and not sharing -- her children's stories:
Everyone wants to know the story of how we adopted three children from Ethiopia. But do I have a right not to tell it, existing as I do right out here on the front line, looking as I do, a Caucasian mom with three African kiddos? Taking my children to the grocery store or to the library without announcing where they came from? Do I have a right to live in the world, fully and enthusiastically and not announce my history or that of my children? I think, yes.

* * *
When we started talking adoption, especially interracial adoption, with other adoptive parents we were told that we would be shocked at the number of people that would ask about our child’s background, effectively his or her life story.

I naively didn’t believe that this would happen. After all, you wouldn’t randomly knock on someone’s door and ask them to share with you private traumas and personal struggles. . . . Still, not a week goes by that I am not asked if my children’s parents are dead, if they are orphans, what happened to them, whether they are “related,” how we “got” them, whether they suffered starvation or other forms of trauma or abuse and how long they were in an orphanage. I am routinely followed by a well-meaning librarian throughout our local library as she tells me stories about orphans. I am stopped at least twice a week by strangers who ask if my kids are “mine.”

Whose Standards?

An interesting article, Whose Standards?, about the difference between state accreditation of an adoption agency and Hague accreditation of an adoption agency, focusing on Celebrate Children International, a Florida-licensed agency denied Hague accreditation based on serious allegations of improper practices.  The Florida department licensed the agency despite receiving the same complaints that prevented Hague accreditation:
The difference between the state's evaluation of Celebrate Children and the Council's assessment reflects in part a challenging and confusing regulatory landscape.

As a practical matter, state licensing agencies can't send their investigators to countries such as Ethiopia and Guatemala to check out complaints about suspect adoption practices. In addition, Florida and other states are hamstrung by state laws written decades before Americans began adopting large numbers of children from abroad.

"International adoption was never on the legislatures' radar screens," says Joni Fixel, a Michigan attorney who has represented a number of prospective adoptive parents in lawsuits against adoption agencies. "They were really focused on what do we need to do to make sure our domestic adoptions are done absolutely correctly, and there's huge gaps because there's this no-man's land called international adoption," says Fixel.

The Council's refusal to accredit Celebrate Children also reflects the difference between the state's standards for compliance and the Hague standards, however.
 So how does this agency stay in the business of international adoption if they are not Hague-accredited?  By dealing with non-Hague countries like Ethiopia, of course:
Information in the agency's licensing file shows that Celebrate Children has turned to Ethiopia as adoptions from Guatemala slowed and eventually ground to a halt. Guatemala became the No. 1 source for children adopted overseas by Americans in 2008 but closed its borders to adoptions in 2009 after reports of widespread corruption, violence and fraud. (While Guatemala implemented the Hague Convention in 2008, the U.S. government doesn't consider it to be Hague compliant.)

In 2007, Celebrate Children reported gross receipts of $5.152 million to the Internal Revenue Service, with 84% of that revenue derived from adoptions in Guatemala, according to an audit. By 2008, Celebrate Children's gross receipts dropped to slightly more than $2 million. One year later, in 2009, the agency's board reported that Celebrate Children was "surviving off Ethiopia" and "Sue agreed to take a pay cut to stay open."

By 2010, Celebrate Children was on better financial footing. "The company is as financially sound and profitable as it was back in October of 2008," minutes from a March 14, 2010, board meeting state. "Ethiopia as a country program has been very profitable to date. Approximate cash balances are $625,000 in the country fee account ... and $115,000 in the office account." "Sue is back to full salary," the board reported.
(Kinda hard to argue that adoption isn't a business with board minutes like these, huh?)

One proposed solution to this problem of minimal licensing requirements is to make state licensing requirements the same as Hague accreditation requirements:

Nistri [spokesperson for the Florida Department of Children and Families, which licenses agencies] acknowledges that the Hague standards are more stringent than the state's. She says she'd welcome a change in state law to make Florida's standards conform with Hague. "We always would prefer to align with a larger federal organization like that, a federal accreditation like that. Their expertise in the development of the Hague has to do with knowledge and exposure to international practice, so we would love that."
My proposed solution, which would show a genuine commitment to the Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption, would be for the U.S. to prohibit adoptions from countries that are not Hague signatories. Until we take that step, more and more international adoption will be from countries with questionable commitments to doing adoption right, through agencies who are only minimally regulated.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Attachment Parenting & Adoption: Is It Ever Too Much?

An adoptive mom asks that question here:
Before I became an adoptive parent, I did my fair share of reading and planning for our new baby. I had in mind how I hoped to parent, but I also knew that my husband [and] I would need to be flexible. We were definitely committed to practicing attachment parenting. Little did we know exactly how much practice we were going to get.

As soon as our son was placed in our arms, we knew we were going to have to take the attachment parenting lifestyle very seriously. As an adoptive parent, you sometimes hear phrases such as "less than ideal" used to describe orphanage conditions. Well, our son’s emotional and physical condition when he came to us made it apparent that "less than ideal" would have been good.

We committed ourselves to doing everything possible to help our son adjust, learn to trust, become comfortable, feel safe and eventually love us. We did that through our own version of attachment parenting, which, if I’m honest, may have taken it to a whole new level. While some things didn’t work because of circumstances, we overdid others.

For example, despite our best efforts, our son couldn’t co-sleep. His behaviors made it apparent that not only was he rarely held, but he had very little personal interaction. He just couldn’t get comfortable with people in such close proximity in the beginning. We ultimately moved him to a crib in his own room, but our responsiveness to his needs was intense and immediate. Some nights, he woke 15 or 20 times. My husband or I would literally run to him -- there was no delay. I even broke a toe one evening, sprinting up the stairs, although, truth be told, I have a history of breaking toes.

We held him whenever he would allow it, which was seldom in the beginning, and spent a lot of time sitting on the floor with him, as close as possible, helping him adjust to being touched and comforted. We held him close and tightly when we fed him, always maintaining eye contact, never allowing him to take his bottle from us, even when he struggled mightily. We didn’t allow anyone else to feed or bathe him.

It probably sounds ridiculous…unless you’ve been there.
Yep, doesn't seem like too much to me, sounds just about right!

Monday, October 25, 2010

"Would you sit with me?"

The other day, Zoe and my mom were having a conversation about what the world was like over 50 years ago, and Zoe asked my mom if it was true about Rosa Parks, and other African-Americans, having to sit at the back of the bus.  My mom told her it was true, and Zoe asked where she would have to sit.  Now, I've had the same conversation with Zoe many times, and I've blogged about the application of Jim Crow laws to Asian Americans, but it's a subject Zoe obviously needs to revisit. 

My mom said she wasn't sure where Asian Americans had to sit on the bus, and Zoe asked, "Well, if I had to sit in the back, would you sit with me?"

Of course my mom assured her that she would sit with Zoe, that she wouldn't let her sit by herself on the bus.

But the question seems like such a cry for belonging, it hurts to hear it.  Zoe needed reassurance that, even in the midst of racial division, she still belongs with her family.  She was seeing herself as a little girl sent to sit by herself, alone and abandoned, at the back of the bus.  Amazing how adoption issues arise when the conversation is about SOMETHING ELSE altogether.

Sunday, October 24, 2010

70-Year-Old Wants to Adopt

OK, it's actually a harder question than you think!  At Adoption Under One Roof, there's this story:
Is 70 too old to adopt a 7 year old boy? A little over a year ago my agency asked me to take another teenage girl, with a catch. She came with a 6 year old brother. . . . These children had just entered foster care, the victims of severe neglect. The agency thought they could really benefit from the attention a grandmother could lavish on them, and they were right.

My little boy arrived even smaller than expected. He was wearing size 3, and I had to run out and buy a car seat for him. At 6 years old, he was quite a bit smaller than my 3 year old granddaughter. Of course, that caused myself and my teenagers to hold and snuggle him even more, something he desperately needed. Over a year has passed and the agency is looking at terminating the parents’ rights, making my sweet little boy and his teenage sister available for adoption. Because the sister is over the age of 14, she can choose whether or not she wants to be adopted. She has chosen to stay with me until she graduates. I just cannot imagine giving up my little boy.

Normal procedure is not to allow a person more than 50 years older than a child to adopt a particular child. I am 63 years older than him, still in good health and active. I am waiting for the agency and courts to make a decision on whether or not they will allow a 70 year old single woman to adopt a 7 year old boy.
So what's the answer?  Should this 70-year-old be allowed to adopt?  Should brother and teen-age sister be split up? Is my argument that there shouldn't be an absolute bar based on age, that it should be decided on a case-by-case basis, sounding better? Or is this case proof-positive that there should be an absolute line drawn? If you were the judge, what would you do in this case?

Indian Court Won't Open Records

From the Mumbai Mirror, a follow-up to this story:
A Netherlands-based clinical psychologist who was adopted in Mumbai has lost her almost 10-year old battle to find her mother. The Bombay High Court ruled on Friday that a promise made to an unwed mother while she was handing over her child, allegedly born out of an illegitimate relationship, cannot be broken.

The HC was hearing a petition filed by Daksha Van Dijck, 35, and Anjali Pawar-Kate of the international NGO Against Child Trafficking.

Daksha was adopted by Dutch national Johan Van Dijck in 1975. When she came to India in 2001 and 2007 in search of her biological parents, she smelt an adoption racket. She was allegedly told by the Shraddhanand Mahilashram — the orphanage-cum-adoption centre which gave her away — that she was an abandoned child. However, Daksha could not find a police report which could substantiate this claim. She lodged a complaint with Matunga police against the centre on February 9 last year stating it should have maintained her confidential information files as mandated by the Supreme Court.

She filed the petition in May this year. In it she has alleged that the orphanage authorities are hiding facts about her birth because she could have been kidnapped for adoption. In June the HC had directed it’s registry to trace the records of the adoption related case. Though the records were traced, they were hardly of any help as they consisted of just a four-five line order.

On Friday, advocate Anjali Purav, appearing for Shraddhanand Mahilashram, submitted before the court that it had promised Daksha’s unwed mother that her (mother’s) identity will not be revealed to anyone. So if Daksha was to be provided with the information about her mother, the promise would automatically be broken.

* * *

The bench also agreed with Shraddhanand Mahilashram on the point of concealing the identity of the unwed mother and hence dismissed the petition.
It seems strange that the court first ordered that the records be tracked down, and then won't follow through.  And despite the court order, the agency only turned over "just a four-five line order," described as unhelpful in searching for her birth mother, even though it seems that they had the name of the birth mother all along!

The promise of confidentiality to birth mothers is often the excuse for closed records in the U.S., too. Elizabeth Samuels, a law professor at the University of Baltimore, has done research on adoption law and relinquishment papers.  She has concluded that lifelong anonymity was never promised to birth mothers.  In fact, she says, "lifelong anonymity was not offered to birth mothers; it was imposed upon them." 

Makes me wonder what promises were made in India . . . .

Saturday, October 23, 2010

Offering to Buy a Baby

Wealthy British entrepreneur James Caan offers to buy a baby, according to this BBC report:
TV cameras filming his charity work captured the multi-millionaire offering 100,000 rupees (£725) for the baby.

He told the girl's parents his brother desperately wanted to have a baby and would be able to provide the best possible life for her.

Mr Caan said he responded emotionally, rather than rationally.

The entrepreneur, born in Pakistan, was looking for a village he could help rebuild in the wake of the August floods that wrought devastation on his country.

The flooding across a swathe of Pakistan left some 2,000 people dead and affected up to 20 million people.

In one village, Mr Caan came across a newborn and made the offer of money in return for the baby.

His exchange was recorded by ITV News.

"I'm being 100% serious," he said to his translator. "My brother lives here and he desperately wants to have a baby.

"We could give this little baby the best life she could ever have."

However in an interview with BBC Radio's 5 Live, he said he regretted his actions.

"In that moment of emotion, you immediately feel there's something you could do," he said.

"What can you do to increase that child's survival? So I offered to help the family by offering to adopt the baby and then on reflection realised that the baby belongs to the family and the village and I'm really here to adopt a village, not a baby."

He said what he did was "clearly not the right thing to do" and he had not been thinking rationally.
I'm glad he regrets the offer and realizes it was wrong -- but what is wrong with our culture that a first emotional response to poverty and crisis is to REMOVE the child from the family, rather than to improve the conditions of the family?  Less wealthy people don't necessarily offer cash -- but they "save the child" via adoption, even when there are living family members who could care for the child if given a little assistance.  Sigh.

Friday, October 22, 2010

Celebrity Adoption: Rod Stewart, Birth Father

Celebrity stories are usually about adopters;  this one is about the reunion of Rod Stewart and the child he relinquished for adoption 46 years ago:
Seven-time father Rod Stewart was virile long before he was rich, and the rocker-turned-crooner is now rekindling hs relationship with the daughter he gave up for adoption when he was a teenager.


Mod Rod told Joy Behar he was "absolutely stone broke" when Sarah Streeter was born and had no other option. "She was put up for adoption when I was 17 or 18, I think," the rocker said Thursday.

Stewart has had sporadic contact over the years with his daughter, now 46, but the two have gotten closer following the deaths of her adoptive parents.

"Since her mom and dad have died, we've tried to come together and be close together, and it's working out pretty well," Stewart said. "I never felt like I was her dad, because I didn't take her to school, change her nappies, there was no paternal thing there, but I'm trying."
I wish I were surprised by the fact that contact was only sporadic before her adoptive parents died, and that they are only now building a real relationship.  But I hear so often from adoptees who won't search or who won't have a relationship with birth parents for fear of hurting their adoptive parents.  What a shame.

Transracial Adoption: Family & Struggle

From ABC News, a report about transracial adoption (from March, but it just came across my radar) -- and it focuses on the voice of adult adoptee Phil Bertelson (yay! I love it when the media LISTENS to adult adoptees!):
A few days ago, Duke and Lisa Scoppa adopted two Haitian orphans, 4-year-old Erickson and 4-month old Therline.

"I just always felt like it would be a really enriching experience for us and for everybody involved, really," Lisa Scoppa said.

Among the things that lie ahead for the Haitian children adopted by white American parents are a better life materially and a chance to grow up in a loving family.

But some black children who were adopted by white parents say there's another side of the story.

"I didn't feel like I was seen or understood," said Phil Bertelsen, who was 4 when he was adopted by a white family and then raised in a mostly white New Jersey suburb.

Bertelsen and other black adoptees tell a similar tale: They felt estranged from the people around them who they instinctively knew from an early age were different from them, and yet cut off from their own racial identity and culture.

"In my teens, I became hungry to be a part of some kind of black community, black identity," Bertelsen said. "What was missed primarily was, you know, strong familiar representations of black life other than the ones I was getting through popular culture and otherwise."

He grew up to be a documentary filmmaker and made his first movie, "Outside Looking In," about transracial adoption. In it, he confronts his own parents for the first time.

"Ultimately, I am a part of your family," he told them in the film. "I use my name with pride. But I am also an African-American in your family and, you know, you have to see me as that."
I missed Bertelson's documentary at the adoption conference -- Thursday night they showed it and three other adoption films, but I didn't arrive in NYC until late that night.  I guess I'll just have to buy it to have another chance to see his film!

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Links: Talking Adoption

Here are some links I've run across recently giving advice about talking to your children about their adoptions:

Who Are You and Where Do You Come From? From the blog MotherlyLaw, comparing what she knows of her biological children and what adoptive parents don't know, and using it as a springboard to offer tips on talking to kids about adoption.  Links to some good books for kids.

Questions About Adoption, from HealthyChildren.org, a site of the American Academy of Pediatrics, reminding parents they have to use the words "adopted" and "birth mother" and "birth father." (I said the same thing here!)

How to Help Your Child Process The Past, from Judy Miller at Parenting Your Adopted Child; if you focus only on the rosy story of adoption, you're not doing your job.

Talking About Difficult Birth Circumstances in Adoption, reminding us that our children need to hear difficult things from us, not from someone else, if they are to trust us.

Talking With Your Adopted Teen:  It's Possible and Important, from the North American Council on Adoptable Children, information on the special challenges of talking to teens about adoption.

Nothing really revolutionary in any of these, but great information for all of us!

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Keeping the Promise: Post-Adoption Services

Speaking of the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute. . .

Adam Pertman, their director, mentioned at the adoption conference that they were going to release a report this week on post-adoption services.  And now they have -- Keeping The Promise: The Critical Need for Post-Adoption Services to Enable Children and Families to Succeed.  From the Executive Summary:
Several months ago, when the media focused the nation's attention on yet another sensational adoption story - this time about a Tennessee mother who put her 7-year-old son on a plane back to Russia – all sorts of disquieting questions flowed through people's minds. They ranged from the rhetorical ("What kind of mother would do such a thing?") to the important ("Are children in orphanages being adequately cared for before adoption?") to the inadvertently stigmatizing ("If a child can be so easily `returned,' is adoption really permanent?").

Most child welfare and adoption professionals watched the drama with better-trained, more-experienced eyes, however, and so they raised very different questions. For example: "Did the mother get accurate information about the boy before adopting, as well as training and education, so she would be prepared for the challenges of parenting a child who had been institutionalized?" And, most pointedly: "Were post-adoption services readily available to her so that she could help her son, and herself, rather than giving up?"

Over the last two decades, our nation has seen steep increases in the number of adoptions from foster care in the United States and from orphanages abroad – which, combined, make up the vast majority of non-stepparent adoptions; i.e., we have made considerable progress in finding enduring families for girls and boys who have suffered from abuse, neglect, multiple placements, institutionalization and other pre-adoption experiences that can cause them physical, psychological, emotional and developmental harm. Now the paradigm has to shift, and our priority must be not only to achieve permanency, but also to assure that adoptive parents receive the supports they need to raise their children to healthy adulthood.
The findings are fascinating, including discussion of why some adopted children are at risk of physical, developmental, psychological, and emotional issues, and the "protective factors" in children and families that can help ameliorate the problems.  I'll write more about it after I've digested this lengthy report.